Marrow Controversy

Marrow Controversy

The Marrow Controversy was a Scottish ecclesiastical dispute occasioned by the republication in 1718 of The Marrow of Modern Divinity (originally published in two parts in London in 1645 and 1649 by "E. F.", generally believed to be a pseudonym for Edward Fisher, an English Calvinist lay theologian of the seventeenth century, belonging to the guild of barber surgeon; not to be confused with Edward Fisher, Esq.). The work consists of religious dialogues which discuss the doctrine of the atonement and aim to guide the reader safely between Antinomianism and Neonomianism.

Contents

History

Thomas Boston

In 1700, while making a pastoral visit in the small country parish of Simprin, in the course of his work as a Church of Scotland minister, Thomas Boston saw and borrowed a copy of The Marrow of Modern Divinity. He greatly appreciated the book and while a member of the 1717 General Assembly, commended it to a fellow minister. As a consequence of this conversation, in 1718 arrangements were made to have the Marrow reprinted, with a preface by James Hog of Carnock.

The book displeased those who comprised the majority in the Church of Scotland, who were inclined to the legalism prevalent in the late 17th century. James Hadow, Professor of Divinity and Principal of St. Mary's College in the University of St Andrews, took the lead in opposing The Marrow, assailing it in his opening sermon at the Synod of Fife in April 1719. This was published shortly thereafter as The Record of God and Duty of Faith Therein required. An interchange of pamphlets with Hog ensued, with Hadow accusing the Marrow of the Antinomian heresy and Hog asserting that Hadow was misrepresenting the Marrow.

Committee for Purity of Doctrine report

At the May 1719 General Assembly, an existing "Committee for Purity of Doctrine" was instructed to "enquire into the publishing and spreading of Books and Pamphlets, tending" to the spread of doctrines "inconsistent with our Confession of Faith" and to call such authors to account. The committee's report, submitted in May 1720, strongly condemned the book as Antinomian. The Assembly overwhelmingly approved this report, prohibited all ministers of the Church of Scotland from recommending The Marrow in any way, and instructed them to warn their people against reading it. This, of course, had the effect of advertising a previously obscure book to people throughout Scotland and many proceeded to buy a copy and to read it carefully.

Representation and Petition

At the Assembly in 1721 twelve men, including Boston, Hog and Ralph and Ebenezer Erskine, submitted a "Representation and Petition", arguing that in condemning The Marrow the Assembly had condemned propositions which were scriptural, and other expressions which were plainly taught both by many orthodox divines and in the doctrinal standards of the Church of Scotland. They also argued that the report had misrepresented the book’s teaching, taking various expressions out of context. Their petition was rejected. In the Assembly of 1722 The Marrow's condemnation was reaffirmed and the twelve Representers were rebuked.

Associate Presbytery

Subsequently every effort was made by the men who had opposed The Marrow to prevent ministers holding Marrow doctrines from obtaining more influential pastoral charges, but no effective disciplinary action was taken against them. The ecclesiastical controversy thus gradually drew to an end, but theological disagreement continued. In the 1730s, though over a different issue, that of patronage, some of the proponents of Marrow theology left the Church of Scotland to form the Associate Presbytery, with the distinctive doctrines of The Marrow forming the theological basis for the new church.

In 1726 a new edition of The Marrow was published, with a preface and extensive annotations by Thomas Boston, defending and expounding the Marrow’s teaching as Scriptural. In this form The Marrow has been frequently reprinted over the last nearly 300 years and has been widely influential.

References

  • C. A. Briggs, American Presbyterianism, pp. 254 sqq., New York, 1885.
  • David C. Lachman,The Marrow Controversy: An Historical and Theological Analysis, Edinburgh: Rutherford House, 1988.
  • W. M. Hetherington, History of the Church of Scotland, chap. ix., pp. 342, 344–347, New York, 1881.
  • N. M. deS. Cameron (editor), Dictionary of Scottish Church History & Theology. Edinburgh, 1993. Various relevant articles.
  • Edward Fisher, The Marrow of Modern Divinity with notes by Thomas Boston. Fearn: Christian Focus Publications, 2009.
  • William VanDoodewaard, The Marrow Controversy and Seceder Tradition, Grand Rapids: Reformation Heritage Books, 2011.

External links


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать курсовую

Look at other dictionaries:

  • MARROW CONTROVERSY —    a theological controversy which arose in Scotland in the 18th century over the teaching of a book entitled The Marrow of Modern Divinity, and which led to a secession from the Established Church on the part of the Marrow men, as the supporters …   The Nuttall Encyclopaedia

  • marrow controversy —  Сущностный спор …   Вестминстерский словарь теологических терминов

  • Marrow — may refer to: Bone marrow, the flexible tissue interior to bone Squash (plant) Marrow (comics), a character in the X Men comic series Marrow (novel), a science fiction novel by Robert Reed The Marrow Controversy, occasioned by the republication… …   Wikipedia

  • Stem cell controversy — The stem cell controversy is the ethical debate primarily concerning the creation, treatment, and destruction of human embryos incident to research involving embryonic stem cells. Not all stem cell research involves the creation, use, or… …   Wikipedia

  • Category:Christianity-related controversies — Differing ideas of Christianity. Subcategories This category has the following 23 subcategories, out of 23 total. A [+] …   Wikipedia

  • Thomas M'Crie the Elder — For his eldest son, of the same name, see Thomas M Crie the Younger.Thomas M Crie (November, 1772 August 5, 1835) was a Scottish historian, writer, and preacher born in the town of Dunse, Berwickshire in November 1772. He was the eldest of a… …   Wikipedia

  • Thomas Boston — (March 17, 1676 May 20, 1732), was a Scottish church leader.He was born at Duns. His father, John Boston, and his mother, Alison Trotter, were both Covenanters. He was educated at Edinburgh, and licensed in 1697 by the presbytery of Chirnside. In …   Wikipedia

  • James Hadow — was Principal of St Mary s College, University of St Andrews from 1707 till 1747. He was the born in Douglas, South Lanarkshire, Scotland on August 13 1667. He died on the 4 May 1747 at St Andrews, Fife, Scotland. Early life and education The… …   Wikipedia

  • United Secession Church — Infobox Christian denomination name = United Secession Church imagewidth = caption = main classification = Protestant orientation = Calvinist polity = Presbyterian founder = founded date = 1820 founded place = separated from = Church of Scotland… …   Wikipedia

  • Boston, Thomas — (1677 1732)    Scottish divine, was successively schoolmaster at Glencairn, and minister of Simprin in Berwickshire, and Ettrick in Selkirkshire. In addition to his best known work, The Fourfold State, one of the religious classics of Scotland,… …   Short biographical dictionary of English literature

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”