Treatments for chronic headaches

Chronic headache, or "chronic daily headache (CDH)", is classified as experiencing fifteen or more days with a headache per month. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 6] It is estimated that chronic headaches affect “4% to 5% of the general population.” [ Mathew, Ninan T. "The Prophylactic Treatment of Chronic Daily Headache" p. 1552] Chronic headaches consist of different sub-groups, primarily categorized as chronic tension-type headaches and chronic migraine headaches. [ Mathew, Ninan T. "The Prophylactic Treatment of Chronic Daily Headache" p. 1552] The treatments for chronic headache are vast and varied. Medicinal and non-medicinal methods exist to help patients cope with chronic headache, because chronic headaches cannot be cured. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 136 ] Whether pharmacological or not, treatment plans are often created on an individual basis. [Harpole, Linda H., et al. "Headache Management Program Improves Outcome for Chronic Heachache" p. 716 ] Multiple sources recommend "multimodal treatment", which is a combination of medicinal and non-medicinal remedies. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 40, "Success with Biofeedback found in Chronic Headache Treatment", Andrasik, F. "Behavioral Treatment Approaches to Chronic Headache" p. S81 ] Some treatments are controversial and are still being tested for effectiveness. Suggested treatments for chronic headaches include medication, physical therapy, acupuncture, relaxation training, and biofeedback. In addition, dietary alteration and behavioral therapy or psychological therapy are other possible treatments for chronic headaches.

Treatments

Medicinal treatments

Analgesic and abortive medications

The most common chronic treatment method is the use of medicine. Many people try to seek pain relief from analgesic medicines (commonly termed pain killers), such as aspirin, acetaminophen, aspirin compounds, ibuprofen, and narcotics. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 88, 95 ] Also, abortive medications can be used to “stop a headache once it has begun”; such drugs include ergotamine (Cafergot), triptans (Imitrex), acetaminophen (Midrin), and prednisone (Deltasone). [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 89, 94 ] However, medical professionals advise that abuse of analgesics and abortive medications can actually lead to an increase in headaches. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 24] The painkiller medicines help headaches temporarily, but as the “quick fix” wears off, headaches become more re-current and grow in intensity. [ Buchholz, David. "Heal Your Headache: The 1-2-3 Program for Taking Charge of Your Headaches" p. 46 ] These “rebound headaches” can actually make the body less responsive to preventive medication. [ Buchholz, David. "Heal Your Headache: The 1-2-3 Program for Taking Charge of Your Headaches" p. 50 ] Therefore, analgesic and abortive medications are often advised for headaches that are not chronic in nature.

Prophylactic (preventative) medications

The most common medicines used to treat chronic (daily) headaches are called prophylactic medicines, which are used to prevent headaches. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 95 ] Such preventative medication is taken on a daily basis, even when a person may not have a headache. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 95 ] Prophylactic medicines are recommended for chronic headache patients because varied experiments prove that the medications “reduce the frequency, severity, and disability associated with daily headaches.” Mathew, Ninan T. "The Prophylactic Treatment of Chronic Daily Headache" p. 1553] A majority of the prophylactic medications work by inhibiting or increasing neurotransmissions in the brain, often preventing the brain from interpreting pain signals. [ Mathew, Ninan T. "The Prophylactic Treatment of Chronic Daily Headache" p. 1553-1560]

Preventative medicines include gabapentin (Neurontin), tizanidine (Zanaflex), fluoxetine (Prozac), amitriptyline (Elavil), and topiramate (Topamax). In testing, gabapentin was found to reduce the number of headache days a month by 9.1%. Tizanidine was found to decrease the average frequency of headaches per week, the headache intensity, and the mean headache duration. [ Mathew, Ninan T. "The Prophylactic Treatment of Chronic Daily Headache" p. 1554] Through studies, Flouxetine resulted in better mood ratings and “significant increases in headache-free days.” [ Mathew, Ninan T. "The Prophylactic Treatment of Chronic Daily Headache" p. 1557] Despite being associated with depression, antidepressants, such as amitriptyline, have been found to effectively treat “near-daily headaches” and numerous chronic pain conditions as well as improving mood and sleep – two possible triggers for chronic headache sufferers. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 99 ] One study found that the headache frequency over a 28-day period lowered for chronic headache patients on topiramate. [ Mathew, Ninan T. "The Prophylactic Treatment of Chronic Daily Headache" p. 1558] Another medication to prevent headaches is botulinum toxin type A (BoNTA or BOTOX), which is given by injection instead of being taken orally. [ Mathew, Ninan T. "The Prophylactic Treatment of Chronic Daily Headache" p. 1553-1558] In a clinical study of botulinum toxin type A, patients participating in the 9-month treatment period with three treatments experienced headache frequency decreases up to 50%. [ Mathew, Ninan T. "The Prophylactic Treatment of Chronic Daily Headache" p. 1559] As with all medications, the preventative medications may have side effects. Since different people respond to drugs differently, chronic headache sufferers may have to go through a “trail-and-error” period to find the right medications. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 91 ] The previously mentioned medicines can improve headaches, but physicians recommend multiple forms of treatments.

Non-medicinal treatments

Physical therapy

In addition to medicines, physical therapy is a treatment to help improve chronic headaches. In physical therapy, a patient works together with a therapist to help identify and change physical habits or conditions that affect chronic headaches. Physical therapy for chronic daily headaches focuses on the upper body, including the upper back, neck, and face. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 109 ] Therapists assess and improve the patient’s body posture, which can aggravate headaches. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 111 ] During office sessions, therapists use manual therapy, such as a massage, stretching, or joint movement to release muscle tension. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 113 ] Other methods to relax muscles include heat packs, ice packs, and “electrical stimulation.” [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 113 ] Therapists also teach chronic headache sufferers at-home exercises to strengthen and stretch muscles that may be triggering headaches. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 113 ] In physical therapy, the patient must take an active role to practice exercises and make changes to his or her lifestyle for there to be improvement. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 113 ]

Acupuncture

Another non-medicinal treatment, which doesn’t require at-home exercises, is acupuncture. Acupuncture involves a certified acupuncturist picking particular points on the body to insert acupuncture needles; these points may differ on an individual basis. [ Coeytaux, Remy R., et al. "A Randomized, Controlled Trial of Acupuncture for Chronic Daily Headache" p. 1115 ] With chronic headache patients, the acupuncturist may needle “tender points at or near the site of maximal headache pain.” [ Coeytaux, Remy R., et al. "A Randomized, Controlled Trial of Acupuncture for Chronic Daily Headache" p. 1115 ] A study conducted by the University of North Carolina School of Medicine found that compared to medicinal treatment alone, medicinal treatment plus acupuncture resulted in more improvement for chronic daily headache patients. [ Coeytaux, Remy R., et al. "A Randomized, Controlled Trial of Acupuncture for Chronic Daily Headache" p. 1121 ] Another acupuncture study in Germany found that 52.6% of patients reported a decrease in headache frequency [ Melchart, Dieter, et al. "Acupuncture for Chronic Headaches--an Epidemiological Study" p. 636 ] In both studies, acupuncture was not the only treatment. Trials show that acupuncture can cause “relevant improvements” for people with chronic headaches. [ Melchart, Dieter, et al. "Acupuncture for Chronic Headaches--an Epidemiological Study" p. 632 ]

Relaxation training

Relaxation training is another form of non-pharmacological treatment for chronic headache. Relaxation training helps to reduce internal tension, allowing a person to control headaches triggered by stress. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 117 ] The different relaxation methods are normally taught by a psychologist or a therapist. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 122 ] Relaxation training works as people become in tune with their own body, allowing them to realize when it is necessary to decrease tension before a headache occurs. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 122 ] The point of relaxation training is to teach people “an attitude of consciously setting out to relax but not trying too hard,” enabling people to relax in everyday situations. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 123 ] Relaxation training includes two different types of methods: physical and mental.

Physical methods

Physical relaxation methods involve actual body movement or action. One physical method for releasing tension involves “purposefully tensing and then relaxing groups of muscles in a definite sequence,” which is named accordingly progressive muscle relaxation. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 124 ] Another physical method of relaxation is deep breathing. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 125 ] Deep breathing is done by breathing from the bottom of the lungs up, which is characterized by the rise and fall of the stomach, not the chest. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 125-126 ] These are the two most common physical methods of relaxation for chronic headache sufferers.

Mental methods

Also, relaxation therapy can involve mental techniques to decrease body tension. The first is called “focused imagery.” [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 128 ] Focused imagery involves concentration on relaxed body parts, followed by focus on tense muscles and imagining that the tense areas are being worked on or relaxed. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 128 ] The next mental technique involves focus on the whole body, instead of its individual parts. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 128 ] In “deepening imagery,” a person imagines the body’s tension as a meter of high to low, and works to reduce tension mentally. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 128 ] An additional mental strategy involves creating and experiencing a location of relaxation in the mind. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 129 ] The last mental strategy involves the chronic headache patient visualizing a place of stress in his or her life and imagining a relaxed response. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 129 ] Meditation in a relaxing environment is also suggested to prevent headaches. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 130 ] Meditation often involves repeating a one syllable sound or staring at a visual object to help focus attention. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 130 ] Relaxation helps the body to unwind, preventing the formation of headaches.

Biofeedback

Biofeedback is often used to evaluate the effectiveness of relaxation training, because it feeds back information to the chronic headache sufferer about the “body’s (biological) current state.” [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 133 ] One of the most common biofeedback tests is the Electromyograph (EMG), which evaluates the “electrical activity” produced by muscles. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 134 ] Biofeedback also can measure electrical brain activity through a test called the Electroencephalograph (EEG). [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 134 ] Another test, called the thermograph, measures skin temperature, because when a person is relaxed they have increased blood flow and a higher temperature. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 134 ] Another method is BVP biofeedback training, which improves chronic headaches by teaching a patient how to regulate and decrease arterial pulse amplitudes by restricting the arteries. [ Martin, Paul R. "Psychological Management of Chronic Headaches" p. 78] When tense, a person’s sweat gland activity increases, which is measured by electrodermograph testing of the hands. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 135 ] Biofeedback methods have been proven to work. A study involving fifteen treatment sessions found that biofeedback was “successful in reducing both frequency and severity of headache at discharge and over time.” [ "Success with Biofeedback found in Chronic Headache Treatment" ] Biofeedback allows headache sufferers to identify problems and then seek to reduce them.

Changes in diet

Many physicians also recommend changes in diet to treat chronic headaches. Many chronic headache sufferers fail to recognize foods or beverages as headache factors, because the consumption may not consistently cause headaches or the headaches may be delayed. [ Buchholz, David. "Heal Your Headache: The 1-2-3 Program for Taking Charge of Your Headaches" p. 65 ] Many of the chemicals in certain foods can cause chronic headaches, including caffeine, monosodium glutamate (MSG), nitrites, nitrates, tyramine, and alcohols. [ Buchholz, David. "Heal Your Headache: The 1-2-3 Program for Taking Charge of Your Headaches" p. 76 ] Some of the foods and beverages that chronic headache sufferers are advised to avoid include caffeinated beverages, chocolate, processed meats, cheese and fermented dairy products, fresh yeast-risen baked goods, nuts, and alcohol as well as certain fruits and vegetables. [ Buchholz, David. "Heal Your Headache: The 1-2-3 Program for Taking Charge of Your Headaches" p. 74-75 ] Additionally, people may have differing dietary triggers on an individualized basis, because not all foods affect people the same way. [ Buchholz, David. "Heal Your Headache: The 1-2-3 Program for Taking Charge of Your Headaches" p. 88 ] Different medical professionals suggest different ways of testing or changing diets. Some may suggest eliminating a few of the potentially headache-causing foods at a time for a short period of time, while others suggest removing all the threatening foods from a person’s diet and slowly adding a couple back at a time. Yet, others may not suggest diet modification at all. [ Buchholz, David. "Heal Your Headache: The 1-2-3 Program for Taking Charge of Your Headaches" p. 71-72 ] The treatment of chronic headaches through changes in diet is based on personal opinion, and, therefore, controversial.

Behavioral therapy and psychological therapy

Also, behavioral therapy and psychological therapy are suggested treatments to reduce chronic headaches. Behavioral therapy and psychological therapy relate closely in their treatment methods, which include a combination of identifying headache stressors, biofeedback, relaxation training, and cognitive-behavioral therapy. [ Martin, Paul R. "Psychological Management of Chronic Headaches" p. 70-85, Andrasik, F. "Behavioral Treatment Approaches to Chronic Headache" p. S80 ] Cognitive-behavioral therapy’s purpose “is to identify and resolve the sources of recurrent stress.” [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 141 ] In treatment studies, patients with medication plus cognitive-behavioral therapy groups did better than groups with medication alone or cognitive-behavioral therapy alone. [ Andrasik, F. "Behavioral Treatment Approaches to Chronic Headache" p. S83 ] Psychological and behavioral therapies identify stressful situations and teach chronic headache patients to react differently, change their behavior, or adjust attitudes to reduce tension that leads to headaches. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 142-145 ] Treatments especially focus on “emotional, mental, behavioral, and social factors” as they impact headaches. [ Andrasik, F. "Behavioral Treatment Approaches to Chronic Headache" p. S80 ] Patients are advised to simply avoid stressors when plausible or share their burdens with others. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 143-144 ] In this way, studies have found that patients with multimodal treatment in a group setting fare better than patients who follow multimodal treatment alone. [Harpole, Linda H., et al. "Headache Management Program Improves Outcome for Chronic Heachache" p. 722 ] Another behavioral study, which included multimodal treatment, showed that the “frequency of severe headaches was reduced by a clinically significant amount for 75% of the patients.” [ Andrasik, F. "Behavioral Treatment Approaches to Chronic Headache" p. S82 ] Behavioral and psychological therapies work to identify and eliminate or reduce stressful situations that lead to chronic headaches.

Beyond behavioral modification, psychological therapy has a few distinct characteristics of its own. It is important to look at the psychological status of a chronic headache sufferer to “identify conditions that might interfere with headaches and treatments,” such as depression. [ Andrasik, F. "Behavioral Treatment Approaches to Chronic Headache" p. S83 ] Also, psychological therapy suggests training in self-hypnosis. [ Martin, Paul R. "Psychological Management of Chronic Headaches" p. 83] While hypnotized, patients are given suggestions to relax and use visual imagery to control headache mechanisms, which is very similar to relaxation therapy. [ Martin, Paul R. "Psychological Management of Chronic Headaches" p. 83] Psychological therapists also analyze personal issues that may interfere in a chronic headache patient’s life, making him or her unable to make changes in lifestyle to improve headaches. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 146-147 ] Psychologist or psychiatric help for chronic headache patients is controversial, as a patient must be open to possible psychological factors in relation to headaches. [ Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need" p. 146-147 ]

Footnotes

References

*Andrasik, F. "Behavioral Treatment Approaches to Chronic Headache." Neurological Sciences: Official Journal of the Italian Neurological Society and of the Italian Society Of Clinical Neurophysiology 24 Suppl 2 (2003): S80-5.
*Buchholz, David. "Heal Your Headache: The 1-2-3 Program for Taking Charge of Your Headaches". New York: Workman, 2002.
*Coeytaux, Remy R., et al. "A Randomized, Controlled Trial of Acupuncture for Chronic Daily Headache." Headache 45.9 (2005): 1113-23.
*Duckro, Paul N. "Taking Control of Your Headaches: How to Get the Treatment You Need". rev ed. New York: Guilford Press, 1999.
*Harpole, Linda H., et al. "Headache Management Program Improves Outcome for Chronic Headache." Headache 43.7 (2003): 715-24.
*Martin, Paul R. "Psychological Management of Chronic Headaches". New York: Guilford Press, 1993.
*Mathew, Ninan T. "The Prophylactic Treatment of Chronic Daily Headache." Headache 46.10 (2006): 1552-64.
*Melchart, Dieter, et al. "Acupuncture for Chronic Headaches--an Epidemiological Study." Headache 46.4 (2006): 632-41.
*"Success with Biofeedback found in Chronic Headache Treatment." Journal of Chiropractic Technique 2.4; 4 (1990): 204.