VAT-free imports from the Channel Islands

Many low-valued exports of goods from the Channel Islands to the United Kingdom are exempt from value added tax (VAT) due to the operation of an EU tax relief called Low Value Consignment Relief (LVCR). LVCR is not limited to the Channel Islands and applies to all low-valued imports into the EU from countries outside of the EU.

Background

Low-value consignment relief

When goods are imported into the EU from a non-EU territory, they are generally subject to a VAT (currently 20% in the UK for most goods). However as a result of EU Council Directive 2009/132/EC, an optional exception is allowed on shipments of a low value to speed up the transit of low value goods which might otherwise be delayed by customs and also reduce the cost of tax collection where it might not be practicable. This administrative relief is known as low value consignment relief (LVCR). Member states which allow the relief must ensure that it does not cause competitive distortion or allow VAT abuse.

The maximum allowed value of the goods for which the exception applies is set by the importing state, and can be between €10 and €22.^[1] The UK has set the limit to €22 (which is £18 at the current exchange rate).

United Kingdom

The United Kingdom is a member of the EU and, as a member state is obligated to apply VAT to a range of goods (see European Union value added tax). Total online retail spending online grew by 33.4% in 2007 to a record £10.9bn and UK online sales are predicted to reach £28.1bn by 2011 – 8.9% of all retail sales.^[2][3] The reasons for the success of internet retail are varied, covering factors related to convenience, time saving, breadth of choice, and price. With reference to online music sales in particular, it has been noted that the low price offered by online retailers such as Play.com, Amazon.co.uk, TheHutgroup.com and HMV plays a significant factor in these sites' popularity.^[4] A study by the Kantar Group found that in 2009 there was an 18% increase in the volume of online CD sales. Many or most of these are shipped from the Channel Islands, although they are almost always controlled by UK-registered parent companies. Furthermore, Kantar found that 95% of such sales are low enough that VAT charges were not applied to them.^[4]

Channel Islands

The Channel Islands consist of the Bailiwicks of Guernsey and Jersey, Crown dependencies which are self-governing but historically linked to the Crown. The Channel Islands have a special relationship with the United Kingdom as set out in Protocol 3 to the United Kingdom's Act of Accession 1972, which formed part of the Treaty of Accession. Under this agreement the Channel Islands are not part of the European Union but are part of the customs territory of the union. This means they do not charge VAT on purchases but there is a free movement of industrial and agricultural goods in trade between the Islands and the Union.

Historical documentation indicates that LVCR was originally allowed by the UK for the Channel Islands in order to expedite Jersey and Guernsey grown agricultural goods such as fresh flowers and daily mail that would have been damaged by the delay caused in VAT processing.^[5][6] More recent documents, including a 2006 States of Jersey Scrutiny Panel, have challenged this claim.^[7][8]

However, in more recent years the Channel Islands have been used as a convenient location for selling goods VAT-free into the UK by mail order. Historically, the bulk of mail order goods sold through the Channel Islands were manufactured in the UK, exported to the Islands and then mailed back into the UK VAT-free. As businesses based in the Channel Islands have become more sophisticated, however, goods are now imported from the Far East, including electronics and accessories.

In a written answer to Janet Dean MP on the 18th of June 2008 the then Financial Secretary to the Treasury Jane Kennedy stated that three quarters of the VAT avoided due to LVCR "is attributable to imports from the Crown dependencies".^[9]

Current status

In recent years, retailers, politicians and academics in the United Kingdom have claimed that this situation affords an unfair and damaging economic advantage to retailers based in the Channel Islands. These retailers are able to offer the same products as UK retailers but at significantly lower prices. The advantage was highlighted by Matt Moulding, CEO of The Hut Group, who was quoted in The Guardian as saying "If you aren't offshore you couldn't possibly compete. Your cost price would be above what people would be retailing at."^[10] The book Last Shop Standing^[11] by Graham Jones (one of the founders of Music Distributor Proper Distribution) details the detrimental effect VAT-free mail order has had on UK music retail, whilst specialist Internet retailers such as freakemporium.com have cited VAT-free mail order as the main factor in their demise.^[12]

Specific products

The Channel Islands require DVDs sold there to be certified by the British Board of Film Classification and therefore only British-certified DVDs are available from the Channel Islands.

CDs are often licensed to specific territories and record companies strongly defend their regional licensing arrangements, as has been shown by the BPI action against play.com when they tried to bring in major label VAT free CDs from outside the EU.^[13]

Memory cards are subject to similar licence arrangements as CDs and DVDs, so the majority of memory cards sold in the Channel Islands are supplied through EU distributors.

Business response

Some UK businesses have claimed that this kind of VAT avoidance is potentially "abusive", in terms characterised by the 2006 Halifax Judgement.^[14] VAT abuse is defined as transactions that, "notwithstanding formal application of the conditions laid down by the relevant provisions of the Sixth Directive and of national legislation transposing it, result in the accrual of a tax advantage the grant of which would be contrary to the purpose of those provisions. Second, it must also be apparent from a number of objective factors that the essential aim of the transactions concerned is to obtain a tax advantage."^[14]

In 2005 a group of UK retailers with the help of the UK trade body The Forum of Private Business gave evidence^[15] to the All-Party Parliamentary Small Shops Group. This group published in 2006 a report High Street Britain 2015 that covered many issues affecting retail in the UK. In relation to LVCR and the Channel Islands it recommended that "The UK Government should immediately apply the lowest threshold applicable for the relief of low value consignments permissible in the directive, which is currently 10 euros (approximately £7) – this would eliminate the vast majority of exploiting trade almost immediately" it also recommended that "The enforcement, by government bodies like Customs and Excise, of VAT should be reviewed to ensure a level playing field" ^[16]

Another group of retailers, called the Retailers Against VAT Abuse Schemes (RAVAS) have filed a complaint with the EU Directorate of Taxation, alleging that the UK Government has breached the Directive covering LVCR by failing to take action to stop abuse.^{[citation needed]} They say that the UK Government could have stopped the growth of LVCR trade by taking legal action against major retailers under Halifax, or by using its discretion to lower the threshold to €10, remove mail order goods from the relief or request the Channel Islands lose the right to benefit from the relief in relation to DVDs and CDs which is known as a 'derogation'.^[17][18] The retailers argue that by failing to stop abuse of LVCR the UK Government is in breach of the Principal VAT Directive (previously the Sixth VAT Directive) which states that the conditions for EU tax exemptions such as LVCR should be laid down "for the purposes of ensuring the correct and straightforward application of those exemptions" and to prevent any "possible evasions, avoidance or abuse".

Government reaction

United Kingdom

Due to pressure from UK retailers and trade body the Forum of Private Business (FPB), the Government of the United Kingdom mentioned the LVCR issue in the 2006 Budget wherein they stated "In 1984, a VAT-free threshold on imports of small commercial consignments from outside the EU was introduced at a level of £18, as an administrative relief. The Government is aware that this provision is currently being exploited the relief now costs the Exchequer around £85 million per year. If the relief continues to be exploited by businesses using offshore locations, the Government will consider changes to prevent this type of behaviour".^[19] However, the UK Government has taken no direct action since 2006, leaving the Channel Islands governments to regulate the trade internally. The UK Government has stated that any action to stop the LVCR trade would damage the UK post office.^[20]

In early 2010 the UK Treasury issued a statement to The Guardian that said "The implication that businesses are simply setting up on the Channel Islands to take advantage of this relief is not true. In fact exports from the Channel Islands account for a very small percentage of the CD/DVD market".^[4]

Jersey

The Channel Islands have no say over the operation of Low Value Consignment Relief as they are not members of the EU and the relief is granted to the importer of the goods and not the exporter. However, the Channel Islands, whilst having no direct influence on the tax policies of the UK government, do regularly discuss taxation issues with the UK Treasury and HM Revenue and Customs as proven by the discussions that took place in 2006 regarding the new Jersey Fulfilment Industry Policy.^[21] Like all EU tax regimes, LVCR is ultimately policed by the EU.

Jersey's Economic Development Minister Philip Ozouf Jr announced in March 2006 a New Jersey Fulfilment Policy^[21] intended to govern the fulfilment industry in the Island and stated that companies who export to the UK by mail order must first obtain a licence. He argued that this was to ensure that the Island was not taken advantage of by UK business and that tangible economic benefits would remain in the Island. In 2007 owing to the bad press generated by the expansion of the fulfilment industry in the Channel Islands, the government of Jersey announced that it had asked certain UK retailers to cease their operations there and that no further licences would be granted for CD and DVD retailers.^{[citation needed]} The refusal to grant further licences was only applied to CDs and DVDs – an industry that is almost entirely based offshore in the Channel Islands already – and licences for other products have not yet been controlled to the same degree.

Guernsey

Guernsey has, like Jersey, taken steps to protect its international reputation and protect the viability of the fulfilment industry in the Bailiwick. In 2007 a Review of the Bulk mail export of DVDs and CDs under the LVCR arrangements was announced^[22] by the Commerce & Employment Department along with the formation of the Guernsey Mail Order and Fulfilment Group which is made up of retailers and fulfilment operators based in the Bailiwick.

In 2008 the Fulfilment Group together with the Guernsey authorities created a Code of Conduct which remains unavailable on the internet but can be obtained from the Guernsey Economic Development Department of the States of Guernsey. The Code is voluntary and acknowledges that in the UK there has been some cause for concern with regards to the relocation of UK companies to the Channel Islands to benefit from the LVCR concession, in particular with the CD and DVD market. It looks to address these concerns through the mutual co-operation of the Guernsey Mail Order and Fulfilment Group and lays down similar trade restrictions to those covered by the Jersey Licence Scheme although unlike that scheme, the only sanction available to those breaking the code appears to be exclusion from the Fulfilment Group. The Guernsey authorities also claim that three of the largest retailers on the Island have agreed to voluntary caps on the amount of VAT that they can avoid by way of LVCR.^{[citation needed]}

Notes

1. ^ Council Directive 2009/132/EC of 19 October 2009 determining the scope of Article 143(b) and (c) of Directive 2006/112/EC as regards exemption from value added tax on the final importation of certain goods
2. ^ http://scotlandonsunday.scotsman.com/business.cfm?id=1180812007
3. ^ http://www.pendle.net/Business/fulllist.htm
4. ^ ^{a b c} Bowers, Simon (19 February 2010). "Boom in sales of tax-free CDs casts doubt on Treasury claims". The Guardian (London). http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2010/feb/19/tax-free-cd-boom-casts-doubt-on-treasury-claims. 
5. ^ "1997 VAT Assurance Review of The Channel Islands" ("Island suppliers were concerned that the introduction of VAT from 1st April 1973 would result in perishable goods, namely cut flowers and cream, not being delivered to customers in peak condition")
6. ^ Tolley's VAT guides
7. ^ ""Letter from Chancellor of the Exchequer George Osborne"". Private Eye 1267. 23 July 2010. 
8. ^ Jersey Economic Affairs Scrutiny Panel – Impact of The Fulfilment Industry On the Local Economy
9. ^ http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200708/cmhansrd/cm080618/text/80618w0016.htm
10. ^ Guardian Article – March 2009
11. ^ http://www.lastshopstanding.co.uk/index.html?_ret_=return
12. ^ http://freakemporium.com/
13. ^ "Online CD Seller in Industry Deal". BBC News. 23 February 2004. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/3514101.stm. Retrieved 18 August 2010. 
14. ^ ^{a b} "Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 21 February 2006 (reference for a preliminary ruling from the VAT and Duties Tribunal, London) — Halifax plc, Leeds Permanent Development Services Ltd, County Wide Property Investments Ltd v Commissioners of Customs & Excise". Official Journal of the European Union. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:C:2006:131:0001:0001:EN:PDF. Retrieved 18 August 2010. 
15. ^ http://www.scrutiny.gov.je/documents/evidence/37591-38482-2262006.pdf
16. ^ BBC News. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/bsp/hi/pdfs/15_02_06_highstreet.pdf. 
17. ^ http://www.parliament.uk/briefingpapers/commons/lib/research/briefings/snbt-04155.pdf
18. ^ http://www.scrutiny.gov.je/documents/reports/36460-45783-2552006.htm
19. ^ "Budget 2006". UK Government. p. 118. http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/+/http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/d/bud06_ch5_180.pdf. Retrieved 12 April 2011. 
20. ^ http://www.parliament.the-stationery-office.co.uk/pa/cm200506/cmhansrd/vo061101/halltext/61101h0011.htm
21. ^ ^{a b} http://www.statesassembly.gov.je/documents/statements/19375-40005-8112006.htm
22. ^ http://www.gov.gg/ccm/commerce-and-employment/press-releases/2007/review-of-the-bulk-mail-export-of-dvds-and-cds-under-the-lvcr-arrangements.en;jsessionid=9EC63A7AB233E7EF060DDA74F0164A3A

References

1. "Are import duties and import VAT always payable?". Notice 143: A Guide for international postal users. Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs. August 2005. http://customs.hmrc.gov.uk/channelsPortalWebApp/channelsPortalWebApp.portal?id=HMCE_CL_000014&propertyType=document#P58_4584. Retrieved 2005-12-29. 
2. ^ Wilson, Bill (2005-06-14). "Call to end CD sales loophole". BBC News. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/4076524.stm. 
3. ^ "New moves to close VAT loophole". BBC News. 2005-07-22. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/jersey/4707463.stm.