Defamation (film)

Defamation (film)
Defamation
Directed by Yoav Shamir
Produced by Sandra Itkoff
Karoline Leth
Philippa Kowarsky
Knut Ogris
Distributed by First Run Features
Release date(s) February 5, 2009 (2009-02-05) (Berlinale)
November 20, 2009 (2009-11-20) (United States)
Running time 91 minutes
Country Israel
Language English
Hebrew

Defamation (Hebrew: השמצה‎; translit. Hashmatsa) is a 2009 documentary film by award-winning filmmaker Yoav Shamir. The film examines antisemitism, and in particular the way perceptions of antisemitism affect Israeli and U.S. politics. The film won Best Documentary Feature Film at the 2009 Asia Pacific Screen Awards.

Contents

Content

The film examines whether "'anti-Semitic' has become an all purpose label for anyone who criticizes Israel and the possibility that some Jews' preoccupation with the past -- i.e., the Holocaust -- is preventing progress in the here and now.[1] Shamir decided to make this film after a critic of an earlier film accused him of antisemitism.[1]

Filmmaker Yoav Shamir states in the beginning of the film that as an Israeli he has never experienced antisemitism himself and wants to learn more about it since references to antisemitism in countries all over the world are common in the Israeli media.

The film includes interviews with Abraham Foxman, the head of the Anti-Defamation League, John J. Mearsheimer, co-author of New York Times Best Seller The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, Norman Finkelstein, a critic of Israeli government policy as well as many others. The film also follows a group of Israeli high school students on a class trip to Europe where they tour Auschwitz, as well as a number of other notable Holocaust locations.

The film notes that in 2007, the ADL reported a spike in antisemitism, claiming that there were 1,500 anti-Semitic incidents in the United States, yet when Shamir contacts the ADL they can only list minor incidents such as websites with inflammatory comments, letters from employees denied time off for a Jewish holiday, or people offended by a cop's use of the word "Jew". A case presented concerns a group of African American boys, aged between 10 and 12, who pelted a school bus with rocks, breaking two windows.

Shamir also interviews a rabbi who says that the hypervigilance of the ADL inflames relations between Jews and non-Jews in the United States. He also finds that among his interviewees there is more sensitivity to antisemitism among secular Jews than religious ones.[1][2]

Reception

Rotten Tomatoes lists 13 positive and 3 negative reviews, giving it an 81% approval rating.[3]

After the film was screened at the Tribeca Film Festival, the Anti-Defamation League issued a statement denouncing the film, stating that it "belittles the issue (of antisemitism) ... and cheapens the Holocaust. It is Shamir's perverse, personal, political perspective and a missed opportunity to document a serious and important issue."

New York Times reviewer Neil Genzlinger states that while these ideas deserve a thorough and dispassionate discussion, Shamir has not provided it in this film. "...it feels like just another day on the Op-Ed page."[4]

Boston Globe reviewer Ty Burr wrote "Unlike many agit-docs, Defamation wants to get you thinking, and it knows the epithet “self-hating Jew’’ can be used as a club by those who don’t want you to think at all." He reviewed the film positively, highlighting how the film argues that raising Israelis to define themselves as a nation of victims is a disservice to modern complexities - and, not coincidentally, makes it almost impossible to see any other people as victims. “Who would I like to kill?’’ one Israeli girl tearfully tells Shamir after touring Auschwitz. “All of them.’’ The filmmaker gently asks us to ask ourselves if this is what “never forget’’ should really mean. [5]

The review in the Los Angeles Times praised the documentary for showing "how accusations of anti-Semitism can easily be exploited for political purposes. The reviewer commended the filmaker for his fairness writing that "even though Defamation, which is sprinkled with unexpected moments of wry humor, will be inescapably controversial, Yoav Shamir strives admirably to be evenhanded."[6]

References

External links


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно сделать НИР?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Defamation — This article is about the malicious statement. For the 2009 film, see Defamation (film). Libel and Slander redirect here. For other uses, see Libel (disambiguation) and Slander (disambiguation). Vilification and Calumny redirect here. For the… …   Wikipedia

  • defamation — de·fa·ma·tion /ˌde fə mā shən/ n 1: communication to third parties of false statements about a person that injure the reputation of or deter others from associating with that person see also libel, slander; new york times co. v. sullivan in the… …   Law dictionary

  • Anti-Defamation League — For other uses, see Anti Defamation League (disambiguation). Anti Defamation League Logo of the Anti Defamation League Motto To stop the defamation of the Jewish people…to secure justice and fair treatment to all. Formatio …   Wikipedia

  • The God Makers (film) — The God Makers is an anti Mormon film produced in 1982 by Ed Decker and Jeremiah Films. The film claims to be an exposé of secrets of the Mormon Church. The church is portrayed as a multi billion dollar corporation that destroys marriages and… …   Wikipedia

  • Munich (Film) — Filmdaten Deutscher Titel: München Originaltitel: Munich Produktionsland: USA Erscheinungsjahr: 2005 Länge: ca. 157 Minuten Originalsprache: Englisch Altersfreigabe …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Outrage (2009 film) — Outrage Directed by Kirby Dick Produced by Amy Ziering …   Wikipedia

  • Outstanding Service to Gay & Lesbian Film — Die GLAAD Media Awards sind erstmals 1990 verliehene Auszeichnungen der US amerikanische Organisation Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation, die jährlich an US amerikanische Medien der Nachrichten und Unterhaltungsindustrie für faire,… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • The Vito Russo Film Award — Die GLAAD Media Awards sind erstmals 1990 verliehene Auszeichnungen der US amerikanische Organisation Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation, die jährlich an US amerikanische Medien der Nachrichten und Unterhaltungsindustrie für faire,… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Vito Russo Film Award — Die GLAAD Media Awards sind erstmals 1990 verliehene Auszeichnungen der US amerikanische Organisation Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation, die jährlich an US amerikanische Medien der Nachrichten und Unterhaltungsindustrie für faire,… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation — Die Gay Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation (GLAAD, dt.: Allianz Schwuler und Lesben gegen Diffamierung) ist eine Non Profit Organisation von LGBT Aktivisten. Sie sieht ihren Zweck darin eine „faire, korrekte und inklusive Darstellung von… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”