Model risk


Model risk

In finance, model risk is the risk involved in using models to value financial securities.[1] Rebonato considers alternative definitions including:

  1. After observing a set of prices for the underlying and hedging instruments, different but identically calibrated models might produce different prices for the same exotic product.
  2. Losses will be incurred because of an ‘incorrect’ hedging strategy suggested by a model.[2]

Rebonato defines model risk as "the risk of occurrence of a significant difference between the mark-to-model value of a complex and/or illiquid instrument, and the price at which the same instrument is revealed to have traded in the market."

Contents

Types of model risk

Burke regards failure to use a model (instead over-relying on expert judgement) as a type of model risk.[3] Derman describes various types of model risk that arise from using a model:[1]

Wrong model
  • Inapplicability of model.
  • Incorrect model specification.
Model implementation
  • Programming errors.
  • Technical errors.
  • Use of numerical approximations.
Model usage
  • Implementation Risk.
  • Data issues.
  • Calibration errors.

Sources of model risk

Interest rate modelling

Buraschi and Corelli [4] formalise the concept of 'time inconsistency' with regards to no-arbitrage models that allow for a perfect fit of the term structure of the interest rates. In these models the current yield curve is an input so that new observations on the yield curve can be used to update the model at regular frequencies. They explore the issue of time-consistent and self-financing strategies in this class of models. Model risk affects all the three main steps of risk management: specification, estimation and implementation.[5]


The volatility smile

Derman believes that products whose value depends on a volatility smile are most likely to suffer from model risk. He writes "I would think it’s safe to say that there is no area where model risk is more of an issue than in the modeling of the volatility smile."[6]

Correlation modelling

Gennheimer investigates the model risk present in pricing basket default derivatives. He prices these derivatives with various copulas and concludes that "... unless one is very sure about the dependence structure governing the credit basket, any investors willing to trade basket default products should imperatively compute prices under alternative copula specifications and verify the estimation errors of their simulation to know at least the model risks they run."[7]

Buraschi, Porchia and Trojani (2010) propose a framework for intertemporal portfolio choice when the covariance matrix of returns is stochastic. An important contribution of this framework is that it allows to derive optimal portfolio implications for economies in which the degree of correlation across different industries, countries, and asset classes is time-varying and stochastic. [8]


Mitigating model risk

Theoretical basis
  • Considering key assumptions.
  • Considering simple cases and their solutions (model boundaries).
  • Parsimony.
Implementation
  • Pride of ownership.
  • Disseminating the model outwards in an orderly manner.
Testing
  • Stress testing and backtesting.
  • Try to simulate model risk.
  • Avoid letting small issues snowball into large issues later on.
Model averaging

Rantala (2006) mentions that "In the face of model risk, rather than to base decisions on a single selected ”best” model, the modeller can base his inference on an entire set of models by using model averaging."[9]

Position limits and valuation reserves

Kato and Yoshiba discuss qualitative and quantitative ways of controlling model risk. They write "From a quantitative perspective, in the case of pricing models, we can set up a reserve to allow for the difference in estimations using alternative models. In the case of risk measurement models, scenario analysis can be undertaken for various fluctuation patterns of risk factors, or position limits can be established based on information obtained from scenario analysis."[10]

Examples of model risk mitigation

Parsimony

Taleb wrote when describing why most new models that attempted to correct the inadequacies of the Black-Scholes model failed to become accepted:

"Traders are not fooled by the Black-Scholes-Merton model. The existence of a 'volatility surface' is one such adaptation. But they find it preferable to fudge one parameter, namely volatility, and make it a function of time to expiry and strike price, rather than have to precisely estimate another."[11]

However Cherubini and Della Lunga describe the disadavantages of parsimony in the context of volatility and correlation modelling. Using an excessive number of parameters may induce overfitting while choosing a severely specified model may easily induce model misspecification and a systematic failure to represent the future distribution.[12]

Model risk properties and implications

Illiquid product model risk

Model risk does not only exit for complex financial contracts. Frey (2000) presents a study of how market illiquidity is a source of model risk. He writes "Understanding the robustness of models used for hedging and risk-management purposes with respect to the assumption of perfectly liquid markets is therefore an important issue in the analysis of model risk in general."[13] Convertible bonds, mortgage backed securities and high-yield bonds can often be illiquid and difficult to value. Hedge funds that trade these securities can be exposed to model risk when calculating monthly NAV for its investors.[14]

Model risk premium

Fender and Kiff (2004) note that holding complex financial instruments such as CDOs "translates into heightened dependence on these assumptions and, thus, higher model risk. As this risk should be expected to be priced by the market, part of the yield pick-up obtained relative to equally rated single obligor instruments is likely to be a direct reflection of model risk."[15]

Difficulty of quantifying model risk

To measure the risk induced by a model it has to be compared to an alternative model. To correctly specify the model risk you have to know an accurate model. However, accurate models are often hard to find. As we cannot always find an accurate model we need a benchmark model giving a close approximation to our data. The problem is how to choose this benchmark model. If we knew the model closest to our data we could easily use this model for risk measurement and model risk would no longer be a problem. Thus, finding a suitable benchmark model is a serious problem. However, it will hardly be possible to overcome this problem when discussing model risk.[16]

Case studies

  • Natwest - Interest rate options and swaptions - incorrect model specification.[17]
  • Bank of Tokyo/Mitsubushi - Interest rate options and swaptions.[18]
  • LTCM - lack of stress testing - Crouhy, Galai and Mark.
  • Barclays de Zoete Wedd (BZW) - Mispriced currency options.[19]

See also

Notes

  1. ^ a b http://www.ederman.com/new/docs/gs-model_risk.pdf Model Risk (1996)
  2. ^ http://www.quarchome.org/ModelRisk.pdf Theory and Practice of Model Risk Management
  3. ^ . >http://www.siiglobal.org/SII/WEB5/sii_files/Membership/PIFs/Risk/Model%20Risk%2024%2011%2009%20Final.pdf
  4. ^ http://www.eco.unipmn.it/eventi/irm/newahead.pdf - Staying Ahead of the Curve: Model Risk and the Term Structure. Andrea Buraschi and Francesco Corielli. (2001)
  5. ^ Buraschi A, Corielli F, 2005, Risk management implications of time-inconsistency: model updating and recalibration of no-arbitrage models, Journal of Banking and Finance 29, Pages: 2883 - 2907.
  6. ^ Emanuel Derman - Laughter in the Dark - The Problem of the Volatility Smile (2003)
  7. ^ Heinrich Gennheimer - Model Risk in Copula Based Default Pricing Models (2002)
  8. ^ Buraschi A., et al., Correlation Risk and Optimal Portfolio Choice, 2010, The Journal of Finance 65, 393-420.
  9. ^ Rantala, J. (2006): ”On joint and separate history of probability, statistics and actuarial science”, Eds. Liksi et al. Festschrift for Tarmo Pukkila on his 60th Birthday, pp261-284, University of Tampere, Finland.
  10. ^ http://www.imes.boj.or.jp/english/publication/mes/2000/me18-2-5.pdf - Model Risk and Its Control - Toshiyasu Kato and Toshinao Yoshiba, Monetary and Economic Studies/December 2000
  11. ^ Dynamic Hedging - Wiley. Nassim Taleb
  12. ^ Structured Finance - Wiley. By Umberto Cherubini, Giovanni Della Lunga
  13. ^ Frey, Rudiger, 2000, Market illiquidity as a source of model risk in dynamic hedging, Model Risk
  14. ^ Managing a Hedge Fund, Keith H. Black, McGraw-Hill Professional (2004) ISBN 978-0071434812
  15. ^ CDO rating methodology: Some thoughts on model and its implications. BIS Working Papers No 163
  16. ^ Measuring Model Risk - Sibbertsen, Stahl and Luedtke, Leibnitz University (2008)
  17. ^ http://www.blackswanrisk.com/advisory5.html Model Validation and Backtesting
  18. ^ http://www.derivativesstrategy.com/magazine/archive/1997/0697fea1.asp Controlling Model Risk
  19. ^ http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m3937/is_/ai_20414680 Model error - evaluation of various finance models

References

  • Rebonato R (2001). ‘Managing Model Risk’ in Handbook of Risk Management. FT-Prentice Hall. 
  • Michel Crouhy, Dan Galai, Robert Mark (2000). Risk Management. McGraw-Hill. 978-0071357319. 

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Model Risk — A type of risk that occurs when a financial model used to measure a firm s market risks or value transactions does not perform the tasks or capture the risks it was designed to. Model risk is considered a subset of operational risk, as model risk …   Investment dictionary

  • model risk — The risk that incorrect or sub optimal interest rate risk management decisions will be made because of errors in the model used to measure risk exposure. Errors may arise from inaccurate data input into the model, from inaccurate assumptions used …   Financial and business terms

  • model risk — / mɒd(ə)l rɪsk/ noun the possibility that a computer model used when investing may have a flaw which makes it function badly in extreme market conditions …   Dictionary of banking and finance

  • Risk — takers redirects here. For the Canadian television program, see Risk Takers. For other uses, see Risk (disambiguation). Risk is the potential that a chosen action or activity (including the choice of inaction) will lead to a loss (an undesirable… …   Wikipedia

  • model — mod‧el [ˈmɒdl ǁ ˈmɑːdl] noun 1. [countable] a particular type or design of a vehicle or machine: • the cheapest model in the Volkswagen range • Our photocopier is the latest model. see also brand1, make2 …   Financial and business terms

  • Risk factors for breast cancer — Risk factors of breast cancer may be divided into preventable and non preventable. Their study belongs in the field of epidemiology. Breast cancer, like other forms of cancer, is considered to result from multiple environmental and hereditary… …   Wikipedia

  • Risk equalization — is a way of equalizing the risk profiles of insurance members in order to reduce premium differences to some predetermined extent.In competitive markets for individual health insurance, risk rated premiums are observed to differ across subgroups… …   Wikipedia

  • Model-driven security — (MDS) means applying model driven approaches (and especially the concepts behind model driven software development) [1] to security. Contents 1 Development of the concept 2 Opinions of industry analysts …   Wikipedia

  • Risk-neutral measure — In mathematical finance, a risk neutral measure, is a prototypical case of an equivalent martingale measure. It is heavily used in the pricing of financial derivatives due to the fundamental theorem of asset pricing, which implies that in a… …   Wikipedia

  • Model audit — A model audit is the colloquial term for the tasks performed when conducting due diligence on a financial model, in order to eliminate spreadsheet error. (Also known as Model Review in some areas). A study in 1998 concluded that even MBA students …   Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.