Novantae

The Novantae were a people of the late 2nd century who lived in what is now Galloway and Carrick, in southwestern-most Scotland. They are mentioned briefly in Ptolemy's Geography (written c. 150), and there is no other historical record of them.

Excavations at Rispain Camp, near Whithorn, show that it was a large fortified farmstead occupied between 100 BC and 200 AD, indicating that the people living in the area at that time were engaged in agriculture.

Their ethnic and cultural affinity is uncertain, with various authorities asserting Brythonic, Pict, Gael, or some combination thereof. However, the region has a history that includes all three as possibilities at various times, alone and in combination, and there is not enough information to disprove any of them.

Ptolemy

The only reliable historical reference to the Novantae is from the Geography of Ptolemy in c. 150, where he gives their homeland and primary towns.^[1] They are found in no other source.

They are unique among the peoples that Ptolemy names in that their location is reliably known due to the way he named several readily identifiable physical features. His Novantarum Cheronesus is the Rhins of Galloway, and his Novantarum promontory is the Mull of Galloway. This pins the Novantae to that area. Ptolemy says that the their towns were Locopibium and Rerigonium. As there were no towns as such in the area at that time, he was likely referring to native strong points such as duns or royal courts.

Roman Era

The earliest reliable information on the region of Galloway and Carrick during the time when the Novantae were known to live there is from archaeology that researches Roman Britain. The only Roman military presence was a small fortlet at Gatehouse of Fleet, in the southeastern part of Novantae territory.^[2] The Roman remains that have been excavated are portable, such as might be carried or transported into the region. The absence of evidence of Roman presence is in sharp contrast to the many remains of native habitation and strong points.^[3][4] Rispain Camp near Whithorn, once thought to be Roman, is now known to be the remains of a large fortified farmstead, occupied by natives before and during the Roman Era.^[5]

In his account of the campaigns of Gnaeus Julius Agricola (governor 78 – 84), Tacitus offers no specific information on the peoples then living in Scotland. He says that after a combination of force and diplomacy quieted discontent among the Britons who had been conquered previously, Agricola built forts in their territories in 79. In 80 he marched to the Firth of Tay, campaigning against the peoples there. He did not return until 81, at which time he consolidated his gains in the lands that he had conquered.^[6]

The homeland of the Novantae, like those of the Damnonii and Votadini, was not planted with forts, suggesting (but not confirming) that the peoples of these regions had reached an amicable understanding with the Romans (such as an unequal alliance). There is no indication that the Romans ever waged war against any of these peoples.

Novant

A kingdom called Novant appears in the medieval Welsh poem Y Gododdin, attributed to Aneirin. The poem commemorates the Battle of Catraeth, in which an army raised by the Gododdin kingdom attempted an ill-fated raid on the Angles of Bernicia. The work elegizes the various warriors who fought alongside the Gododdin, among them the "Three Chiefs of Novant" and their substantial retinue.^[7] This Novant is evidently related to the Novantae tribe of the Iron Age.^[8]

Contradicting Ptolemy

Ptolemy's placement of the Selgovae town of Trimontium was accepted to be somewhere along the southern coast of Scotland until William Roy (1726 – 1790) placed it far to the east at Eildon Hills, near Newstead. Roy was trying to follow an itinerary given in the 1757 De Situ Britanniae, and moving Ptolemy's Trimontium made the itinerary seem more logical according to his historical work, Military Antiquities of the Romans in North Britain (1790, published postumously in 1793). Roy did not alter Ptolemy's placement of the Selgovae in southern Scotland, but chose to assign Trimontium to a different people who were described in De Situ Britanniae.^[9]

Location of the Selgovae town of Trimontium according to Roy, who was trying to reconcile problems with the spurious De Situ Britanniae.

When De Situ Britanniae was debunked as a fraud in 1845, Roy's misguided placement of Trimontium was retained by some historians, though he was no longer cited for his contribution. Furthermore, some historians not only accepted Roy's placement of Trimontium, but also returned the town to the Selgovae by moving their territory such that they would be near Eildon Hills. Ptolemy's placement of the Novantae in Galloway was retained, and since Ptolemy said that they were adjacent to the Selgovae, Novantae territory was greatly expanded beyond Galloway to be consistent with this thesis, which survives in a number of modern histories.^[10]

The result is that an 'error correction' to the sole legitimate historical reference (Ptolemy), made so that a fictional itinerary in De Situ Britanniae would seem more logical, is retained; and the sole legitimate historical reference is further 'corrected' by moving the Selgovae far from their only known location, greatly expanding Novantae territory in the process.

While Roy's historical work is largely ignored due to his unknowing reliance on a fraudulent source, his maps and drawings are untainted, and continue to be held in the highest regard.

Treatment by historians

Befitting the single historical mention of the Novantae by Ptolemy, many historians have largely included the Novantae im passim in their works, if they are mentioned at all. William Forbes Skene (Celtic Scotland, 1886) briefly relates their notice in Ptolemy, adding his conjectures as to the possible locations of towns, though not with any conviction.^[11] John Rhys (Celtic Britain, 1904) mentions the Novantae in passing, without any detailed discussion.^[12] Local Galwegian historians, writing histories of their own home territory, provide a similarly scant treatment.^{[13][14][15][16]}

More recent histories largely treat the Novantae in passing, but often weave them into a story that is not supported by either Ptolemy's map or archaeological evidence. John Koch (Celtic Culture, 2005) doesn't discuss the Novantae directly, but associates their name with the Trinovantes of southeastern England, and provides a map showing the "Novant" occupying Galloway and the Stewartry of Kirkcudbright to accompany his discussion of the Gododdin.^[17] Barry Cunliffe, an archaeologist, (Iron Age Communities in Britain, 1971) mentions the Novantae in passing, saying their homeland was Galloway and the Stewartry of Kirkcudbright, and with a map showing it, which he attributes to "various sources".^[18] David Mattingly (An Imperial Possession: Britain in the Roman Empire, 2006) mentions them as a people of southwestern Scotland according to Ptolemy, with maps showing them as occupying both Galloway and the Stewartry of Kirkcudbright.^[19] Sheppard Frere (Britannia: A History of Roman Britain, 1987) mentions the Novantae several times in passing, associating them firmly with the Selgovae and sometimes with the Brigantes. He places them in both Galloway and the Stewartry of Kirkcudbright, with the Selgovae on the other side of the Southern Uplands in southeastern Scotland.^[20] The Novantae are inconsequential to the larger history of Scotland in Before Scotland: The Story of Scotland Before History (2005) by Alistair Moffat, but he weaves a number of colorful though questionable details about them into his story. He says that their name means 'The Vigorous People', that they had kings and often acted in concert with the Selgovae and Brigantes, all of whom may have joined the Picts in raids on Roman Britain.^[21] He provides no authority for any of these assertions.

See also

• Ptolemy's Geography
• Britannia (Roman province)
• Scotland during the Roman Empire

Citations

1. ^ Ptolemy 150, Geographia 2.2, Albion Island of Britannia.
2. ^ Frere 1987:88 – 89, 112 – 113, 130 – 131, 142 – 143, 347 – 348, Britannia
3. ^ Maxwell 1891:8 – 9, Roman Remains, A History of Dumfries and Galloway
4. ^ M'Kerlie 1877:1 – 2, Wigtonshire.
5. ^ Harding 2004:62. Reports on the excavations were published in 1983.
6. ^ Tacitus 98:364 – 368, Life of Agricola, Chapters 19 – 23.
7. ^ Skene 1868:380 – 381, XVIII, The Gododdin
8. ^ Koch 1997:lxxxii–lxxxiii
9. ^ Roy 1790:115 – 119, Military Antiquities, Book IV, Chapter III
10. ^ Cunliffe 1971:216 – see, for example, the influential Iron Age Communities in Britain, map of the tribes of Northern Britain, attributed to "various sources"
11. ^ Skene 1886:72, Celtic Scotland
12. ^ Rhys 1904:222, 223, 227, 232, Celtic Britain
13. ^ Agnew 1891:1,1 2, 10, 41, The Hereditary Sheriffs of Galloway
14. ^ Maxwell 1891:2, 3, 4, 7, 10, 14,23, A History of Dumfries and Galloway
15. ^ M'Kerlie 1877:14, 15, 22 – 25, 27, 28, 31, 36, 71, History of the Lands and their Owners in Galloway
16. ^ M'Kerlie 1891:14 – 17, Galloway in Ancient and Modern Times, Ptolemy's Geography.
17. ^ Koch 2005:824, 825, 1689, Celtic Culture, Gododdin and Trinovantes.
18. ^ Cunliffe 1971:215 – 216, Iron Age Communities in Britain, Southern Scotland: Votadini, Novantae, Selgovae and Damnonii.
19. ^ Mattingly 2006:49, 148, 423, 425, An Imperial Possession: Britain in the Roman Empire
20. ^ Frere 1987:42, 90, 92, 93, 107, 111, 134, 355, Britannia
21. ^ Moffat 2005:212, 231, 248, 272, 275, 277, 279, 280, 302, 306, Before Scotland: The Story of Scotland Before History

References

• Agnew, Andrew (1891), Agnew, Constance, ed., The Hereditary Sheriffs of Galloway, I (2 ed.), Edinburgh: David Douglas, 1893, http://books.google.com/?id=02NJAAAAMAAJ&pg=PR3 
• Bertram, Charles (1757), Hatcher, Henry, ed., The Description of Britain, Translated from Richard of Cirencester, London: J. White and Co, 1809, http://books.google.com/?id=OwJIAAAAMAAJ&printsec=frontcover 
• Cunliffe, Barry W. (1971), Iron Age Communities in Britain (4th ed.), Routledge (published 2005), p. 216, ISBN 0415347793 
• Frere, Sheppad Sunderland (1987), Britannia: A History of Roman Britain (3rd, revised ed.), London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, ISBN 0-7102-1215-1 
• Harding, Dennis William (2004), "The Borders and southern Scotland", The Iron Age in northern Britain: Celts and Romans, natives and invaders, Routledge, p. 62, ISBN 0-415-30149-1 
• Koch, John T., ed. (1997), The Gododdin of Aneirin: Text and Context from Dark-Age North Britain, University of Wales Press, ISBN 0708313744 
• Koch, John T., ed. (2005), Celtic Culture: A Historical Encyclopedia, ABL-CLIO (published 2006), ISBN 9781851094400 
• Mattingly, David (2006), An Imperial Possession: Britain in the Roman Empire, London: Penguin Books (published 2007), ISBN 978-0-140-14822-0 
• Maxwell, Herbert (1891), A History of Dumfries and Galloway, Edinburgh: William Blackwood and Sons (published 1896), http://books.google.com/?id=Sl0JAAAAIAAJ&printsec=frontcover 
• Moffat, Alistair (2005), Before Scotland: The Story of Scotland Before History, New York: Thames and Hudson, ISBN 978-0-500-28795-8 
• M'Kerlie, Peter Handyside (1877), "General History", in M'Kerlie, Immeline M. H., History of the Lands and Their Owners In Galloway With Historical Sketches of the District, I (2 ed.), Paisley: Alexander Gardner, 1906, http://books.google.com/?id=rV8JAAAAIAAJ&printsec=frontcover 
• M'Kerlie, Peter Handyside (1891), Galloway in Ancient and Modern Times, Edinburgh: William Blackwood and Sons, http://books.google.com/?id=S51nAAAAMAAJ&printsec=frontcover 
• Ptolemy (c. 140), Thayer, Bill, ed., Geographia, Book 2, Chapter 2: Albion island of Britannia, LacusCurtius website at the University of Chicago, 2008, http://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Gazetteer/Periods/Roman/_Texts/Ptolemy/2/2*.html, retrieved 2008-04-26 
• Rhys, John (1904), Celtic Britain (3rd ed.), London: Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge, http://books.google.com/?id=DGsNAAAAIAAJ&printsec=titlepage 
• Roy, William (1790), "Military Antiquities of the Romans in North Britain", Digital Library, National Library of Scotland (published 2007), http://www.nls.uk/maps/roy/antiquities/index.html 
• Skene, William Forbes (1868), The Four Ancient Books of Wales, I, Edinburgh: Edmonston and Douglas, pp. 380 – 381, http://books.google.com/?id=xeEIAAAAQAAJ&printsec=frontcover 
• Skene, William Forbes (1886), Celtic Scotland: A History of Ancient Alban (History and Ethnology), I (2nd ed.), Edinburgh: David Douglas, http://books.google.com/?id=_kcNAAAAIAAJ 
• Tacitus, Cornelius (98), "The Life of Cnaeus Julius Agricola", The Works of Tacitus (The Oxford Translation, Revised), II, London: Henry G. Bohn (published 1854), pp. 343 – 389, http://books.google.com/books?id=GMRJ5aWahRUC&pg=PA343