Perez v. Sharp

Perez v. Sharp

-! bgcolor="#FFD700" | Case opinions
- |
-! bgcolor="#FFD700" | Laws applied
-
U.S. Const. Amend. XIV cl. 1, and Cal. Civ.Code, §§ 60, 69, 69a

In 1948, in the case "Perez v. Sharp" [32 Cal. 2d 711, 198 P. 2d 17 (Cal. 1948).] , also known as "Perez v. Lippold" and "Perez v. Moroney", the Supreme Court of California recognized that interracial bans on marriage violated the Fourteenth Amendment of the Federal Constitution.

The four-to-three decision was authored by Associate Justice Roger J. Traynor who would later serve as the Court's Chief Justice. The dissent was written by Associate Justice John W. Shenk the second-longest serving member in the Courts' history and an important judicial conservative of his day. The opinion was the first of any state to strike down an antimiscegenation law.

Background

Andrea Perez (a Mexican American woman) and Sylvester Davis (an African American man) met while working in the defense industry in Los Angeles. [See Dara Orenstein, Void for Vagueness: Mexicans and the Collapse of Miscegenation Law in California, 74 Pac. Hist. Rev. 367, 367-68 (2005).] "Their romance blossomed beyond the watchful eyes of their families, particularly the Perez parents. The couple saw marriage as a natural outcome of the love they had come to feel for one another." [Rachel F. Moran, Loving and the Legacy of Unintended Consequences, 2007 Wis. L. Rev. 239, 249-50.]

Perez and Davis applied for a marriage license with the County Clerk of Los Angeles. On the application for a marriage license, Andrea Perez listed her race as “white,” and Sylvester Davis identified himself as “Negro.” Under the California law, individuals of Mexican ancestry generally were classified as white.

The County Clerk (named W.G. Sharp) refused to issue the license based on California Civil Code Section 60, which provided that “All marriages of white persons with Negroes, Mongolians, members of the Malay race, or mulattoes are illegal and void,” and also on Section 69, which stated that ". . . no license may be issued authorizing the marriage of a white person with a Negro, mulatto, Mongolian or member of the Malay race". [California Civil Code, section 69.] At the time, California's anti-miscegenation statute had banned interracial marriage since 1850, when it first enacted a statute prohibiting whites from marrying blacks or mulattoes.

Perez petitioned the California Supreme Court for an original Writ of Mandate to compel the issuance of the license. Perez and Davis were both Catholics and wanted to marry in a mass in a Catholic Church. One of their primary arguments was that the Church was willing to marry them, and the state's antimiscegenation law infringed on their right to participate fully in the sacraments of their religion, including the sacrament of matrimony. [Rachel F. Moran, Loving and the Legacy of Unintended Consequences, 2007 Wis. L. Rev. 239, 268.]

The Opinion

The court held that marriage is a fundamental right and that laws restricting that right must not be based solely on prejudice. The court held that restrictions due to discrimination violated the constitutional requirements of due process and equal protection of the laws. The opinion voided the California statute, holding that Section 69 of the California Civil Code was too vague and uncertain to be enforceable restrictions on the fundamental right of marriage and that they violated the Fourteenth Amendment by impairing the right to marry on the basis of race alone.

ignificance

By its decision in this case, the California Supreme Court became the first court of the twentieth century to hold that a state anti-miscegenation law violates the Federal Constitution. [cite book | last = Kennedy | first = Randall | authorlink = Randall Kennedy | title = Interracial Intimacies | publisher = Vintage Books | date = 2003 | pages = 259-266 | isbn = 0375702644 ] It preceded "Loving v. Virginia", the case in which the Supreme Court invalidated all such state statutes, by 19 years, and antedated the civil rights milestones such as "Brown v. Board of Education" from which Loving benefited. Indeed, in "Loving", Chief Justice Warren cited "Perez" in footnote five, and at least one scholar has discussed the extent to which Perez influenced his opinion. [See R.A. Lenhardt, "The Story of Perez v. Sharp: Forgotten Lessons on Race, Law, and Marriage", in "Race Law Stories" (Rachel F. Moran & Devon Carbado eds., forthcoming 2008).]

The California Supreme Court also based much of its 2008 decision "In re Marriage Cases" (2008) 43 Cal.4th 757, which declared that the portions of California law which restrict marriage to be between a man and a woman to be unconstitutional, on "Perez".

References

External links

* [http://lmaw.org/freedom/docs/CA-Perez.pdf Full text opinion of case (PDF)]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно решить контрольную?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Erica Sharp — Erica Jo Sharp (* 29. März 1975 in Ganges) ist eine ehemalige kanadische Ringerin. Sie wurde 1999 Vize Weltmeisterin in der Gewichtsklasse bis 51 kg Körpergewicht Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Werdegang 2 Internationale Erfloge 3 Kanadische …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Gene Sharp — (né le 21 janvier 1928) est un politologue américain connu pour ses nombreux écrits sur la lutte non violente. Il a été parfois surnommé le « Machiavel de la non violence » ou le « Clausewitz de la guerre non… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Adolfo Perez Esquivel — Adolfo Pérez Esquivel Pour les articles homonymes, voir Perez. Fichier:Esquivel.jpg Adolfo Pérez Esquivel Adolfo Pérez Esquivel est un artiste argentin engagé qui a reçu le Prix Nobel de la paix pour son travail de défense des Droits Humains. Il… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Adolfo Pérez Esquivel — Pour les articles homonymes, voir Perez. Adolfo Pérez Esquivel Adolfo Pérez Esquivel est un artiste argentin engagé qui a reçu le Prix Nobel de la …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Martín Pérez (baseball) — Martin Perez Texas Rangers No. – Pitcher Born: April 4, 1991 (1991 04 04) (age 20) Guanare, Portuquesa …   Wikipedia

  • Vicente Pérez Rosales National Park — Infobox protected area | name = Vicente Pérez Rosales National Park iucn category = II caption = Petrohué Waterfalls (Saltos del Petrohué) locator x = locator y = location = Los Lagos Region, Chile nearest city = Puerto Varas lat degrees = 41 lat …   Wikipedia

  • Loving v. Virginia — SCOTUSCase Litigants=Loving v. Virginia ArgueDate=April 10 ArgueYear=1967 DecideDate=June 12 DecideYear=1967 FullName=Richard Perry Loving, Mildred Jeter Loving v. Virginia Citation=87 S. Ct. 1817; 18 L. Ed. 2d 1010; 1967 U.S. LEXIS 1082… …   Wikipedia

  • Mexican American — Mexican Americans 1st row: Bill Richardson • Salma Hayek • Roy Benavidez • Hilda Solis 2nd row: Rosa Gumataotao Rios • Carlos Santana • Jessica Alba • César Chávez 3rd row: Robert Rodriguez • Eva Longoria • Cain Velasquez • …   Wikipedia

  • Miscegenation — Race Classification Race (classification of humans) Genetics …   Wikipedia

  • Roger J. Traynor — Roger John Traynor (February 12, 1900 ndash; May 14, 1983) served as the 23rd Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of California from 1964 to 1970, and as an Associate Justice from 1940 to 1964. A nationally respected jurist, Traynor s thirty year… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”