Shadows of the Mind

Shadows of the Mind

Infobox Book
name = Shadows of the Mind: A Search for the Missing Science of Consciousness


image_caption =
author = Roger Penrose
illustrator =
cover_artist = Joel Nakamura
country = USA
language = English
series =
subject = Artificial Intelligence, mathematics, & quantum mechanics
publisher = Oxford University Press, 1st edition
release_date = 1994 (1st ed.)
media_type = Hardback
pages = 457 pages
isbn = ISBN 0-19-853978-9 (1st ed.)
preceded_by =

"Shadows of the Mind: A Search for the Missing Science of Consciousness" is a 1994 book by mathematical physicist Roger Penrose, and serves as a followup to his 1989 book "".

In the book, Penrose expounds upon his previous assertions that human consciousness is non-algorithmic, and thus is not capable of being modeled by a conventional Turing machine-type of digital computer. Penrose hypothesizes that quantum mechanics plays an essential role in the understanding of human consciousness, specifically that microtubules within neurons provide the brain with the hardware necessary to perform quantum computation and therefore that the collapse of the quantum wavefunction plays an important role in brain function.

In "Shadows of the Mind", Penrose takes a new approach in arguing that consciousness is non-algorithmic, attempting a mathematical proof using Gödel's Incompleteness Theorem.

Criticism

Penrose's views on the human thought process are not widely accepted in scientific circles (Drew McDermott [http://psyche.cs.monash.edu.au/v2/psyche-2-17-mcdermott.html Penrose is Wrong] Drew McDermott, PSYCHE, 2(17), October, 1995] , David Chalmers [http://psyche.cs.monash.edu.au/v2/psyche-2-09-chalmers.html Minds, Machines, And Mathematics - A Review of Shadows of the Mind by Roger Penrose] David J. Chalmers, "PSYCHE" 2(9) June 1995] and others). According to Marvin Minsky, because people can construe false ideas to be factual, the process of thinking is not limited to formal logic. Further, AI programs can also conclude that false statements are true, so error is not unique to humans. Another dissenter, Charles Seife, has said, "Penrose, the Oxford mathematician famous for his work on tiling the plane with various shapes, is one of a handful of scientists who believe that the ephemeral nature of consciousness suggests a quantum process."

In May 1995 Stanford mathematician Solomon Feferman attacked Penrose's approach on multiple grounds, including the mathematical validity of his Gödelian argument and theoretical background. [http://psyche.cs.monash.edu.au/v2/psyche-2-07-feferman.html Penrose's Gödelian argument] ( [http://math.stanford.edu/~feferman/papers/penrose.pdf PDF] ) Feferman, "PSYCHE" 2(7) May 1995] In 1996 Penrose offered a consolidated reply to many of the criticisms of 'Shadows'. [http://psyche.cs.monash.edu.au/v2/psyche-2-23-penrose.html Beyond the Doubting of a Shadow - A Reply to Commentaries on Shadows of the Mind] Roger Penrose, "PSYCHE", 2(23), January 1996]

John Searle criticizes Penrose's appeal to Gödel as resting on the fallacy that all computational algorithms must be capable of mathematical description. As a counter-example, Searle cites the assignment of license plate numbers to specific vehicle identification numbers, in order to register a vehicle. According to Searle, no mathematical function can be used to connect a known VIN with its LPN, but the process of assignment is quite simple - namely, "first come, first serve" - and can be performed entirely by a computer. [Searle, John R. "The Mystery of Consciousness". 1997. ISBN 0940322064. pp 85-86.]

Microtubule hypothesis

Penrose and Stuart Hameroff have constructed a theory in which human consciousness is the result of quantum gravity effects in microtubules. But Max Tegmark, in a paper in "Physical Review E", calculated that the time scale of neuron firing and excitations in microtubules is slower than the decoherence time by a factor of at least 1010. The reception of the paper is summed up by this statement in his support: "Physicists outside the fray, such as IBM's John Smolin, say the calculations confirm what they had suspected all along. 'We're not working with a brain that's near absolute zero. It's reasonably unlikely that the brain evolved quantum behavior', he says." The Tegmark paper has been widely cited by critics of the Penrose-Hameroff proposal. It has been claimed by Hameroff to be based on a number of incorrect assumptions, but Tegmark in turn has argued that the critique is invalid.

ee also

* "The Emperor's New Mind"
* Quantum mind
* "", a 2004 book by Penrose
* Alan Turing, creator of the Turing test

Notes and references

"This article includes [http://www.1729.com/consciousness/godel.html text originally by Philip Dorrell] which is licensed under the GFDL"


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем сделать НИР

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Children of the Mind —   …   Wikipedia

  • Aberrations of the Mind — Infobox Album | Name = Aberrations of the Mind Type = Album Artist = Morgana Lefay Released = March 19th, 2007 Recorded = Studio Soundcreation, Bollnäs, Sweden Genre = Heavy metal Thrash metal Length = Label = Black Mark Records Producer =… …   Wikipedia

  • Odyssey of the Mind — Founder(s) Dr. C. Samuel Micklus, Dr. Theodore Gourley Type Creative Problem Solving Competition Founded 1978 Origins Glassboro State College, New Jersey …   Wikipedia

  • Splinter of the Mind's Eye — Infobox SW Books name = Star Wars: Splinter of the Mind s Eye title orig = translator = author = Alan Dean Foster cover artist = editor = country = USA language = English era = Rebellion canon = C subject = Star Wars genre = Science Fiction… …   Wikipedia

  • The Emperor's New Mind — The Emperor s New Mind: Concerning Computers, Minds and The Laws of Physics is a 1989 book by mathematical physicist Sir Roger Penrose.Penrose presents the argument that human consciousness is non algorithmic, and thus is not capable of being… …   Wikipedia

  • The Science of God — is a book by Alister McGrath summarising his three volume A Scientific Theology .ectionsIntroduction1. Prolegomena2. Nature3. RealityIn this section McGrath suggests inter alia that one approach to the failure of the Enlightenment is to argue for …   Wikipedia

  • The Reasoning — are a rock band from Cardiff, formed in August 2005. They consist of bassist Matthew Cohen, Dylan Thompson (guitar and vocals), Gareth Jones (keyboards and vocals), Owain Roberts (guitar), Vinden Wylde (drums) and the award winning singer Rachel… …   Wikipedia

  • The Straitjacket Lottery — Infobox Film name = The Straitjacket Lottery image size = caption = Theatrical Poster director = Doug Karr producer = Sierra Bellows Doug Karr Rick Saulnier Emmerson Denney writer = Sierra Bellows Doug Karr starring = Andy Jones David Huband Tara …   Wikipedia

  • The Vampire Diaries (novel series) — The Vampire Diaries The Vampire Diaries: Return: Midnight The Awakening The Struggle The Fury Dark Reunion The Return: Nightfall The Return: Shadow Souls The Return: Midnight The Hunters: Phantom The Hunters: Moonsong …   Wikipedia

  • Mind Garage — Top Row L R Ted Smith, Norris Lytton Bottom Jack Bond, John Vaughan Center Larry McClurg, . Background information Origin Morgantown, West Virginia …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”