Re Eskimos

Re Eskimos

-! bgcolor="6699FF" | Case opinions
- |"Re Eskimos" [1939] S.C.R. 104, is a decision by the Supreme Court of Canada regarding the constitutional status of Canada's Inuit people, then called "Eskimos." The case concerned section 91(24) of the "Constitution Act, 1867", then the "British North America Act, 1867", which assigns jurisdiction over "Indians, and Lands reserved for the Indians" to the federal government. The Supreme Court found that for the purposes of section 91(24), Inuit should be considered Indians.

Background

The case arose due to controversy as to whether Inuit in Quebec were under federal or provincial jurisdiction. The Supreme Court noted that when the British North America Act was originally adopted, there were "few, if any" Inuit in Canada, which was then a much smaller country. However, the Constitution always left open the possibility of joining Canada with other lands, and thus the Inuit in Rupert's Land were now within Quebec's borders.

The federal government at the time of this case did not want to take responsibility over the Inuit. It argued that the term "Indians" as defined by the Royal Proclamation of 1763 would not include the Inuit, and that this document could be used to help interpret the British North America Act.

Decision

Duff

Chief Justice Lyman P. Duff, in his opinion, consulted what he believed to be "the most authoritative" evidence, namely evidence from the Hudson's Bay Company. That company used to govern Rupert's Land, and a government committee under the British House of Commons in 1856 and 1857 examined how the company dealt with the Inuit. The Hudson's Bay Company prepared a report for the committee, and as Duff noted, the report referred to Inuit as a type of "Indian." Later, after the British North America Act was adopted, the Parliament of Canada declared in December 1867 that if it gained jurisdiction over Rupert's Land, it would take responsibility for the Indians there. In 1870, the territories were awarded to Canada.

Duff then added that the Inuit of Labrador, as well, had been widely referred to as Indians from around 1760 and were when the British North America Act was adoped. Official records from 1762 called Inuit "savages", and Duff compared this to how Indian tribes such as the Montagnais and Huron were called savages. In 1869, a judge from the Court of Labrador prepared a report for the Governor of Newfoundland which referred to "Esquimaux" (Inuit) as a type of Indian. Duff also found some missionaries referred to Inuit as Indians. In this context, Duff found it important that in 1879, John A. Macdonald, one of the chief negotiators of the British North America Act and Prime Minister of Canada, discussed the Inuit with Sir Hector Langevin, and the discussion referenced the Inuit as Indians.

As defined by the Royal Proclamation of 1763, Indians are "the several nations or tribes of Indian with whom We are connected and who lived under Our protection." The federal government argued this would not include the Inuit, as the words "nations" and "tribes" were not used to describe Inuit communities. However, Duff found evidence contradicting this. Duff also said the Inuit under the Hudson's Bay Company to an extent lived under the "protection" of the Crown, "under either charter or license from the Crown." Duff also doubted that the Royal Proclamation of 1763 could guide interpretation of the British North America Act.

Justices Albert Hudson and Henry Hague Davis each wrote brief opinions concurring with Duff.

Cannon

Justice Cannon wrote his own opinion finding the Inuit should be considered Indians. He noted the report by Sir George Simpson in 1857 calling Inuit Indians. Cannon then concluded, "the report of the Committee must have been known to the Legislature at Westminster in 1867." He also pointed to the Quebec Conference of 1864, in which a resolution declaring the Parliament should govern Indians translated into French as "Les Sauvages et les terres réservées pour les Sauvages." This meant all natives in British North America, including Newfoundland.

Kerwin

Justice Patrick Kerwin also wrote an opinion finding that Inuit were Indians. He felt the British North America Act, in referring to Indians, was intended to mean aboriginals. He noted evidence that Samuel de Champlain, missionaries and others classified Indians as "sauvages" and Inuit as "sauvages esquimaux." Books which Kerwin speculated that the Fathers of Confederation and the British Parliament in 1867 might have seen also used this classification. Editions of Webster's Dictionary from 1913 and the 1920s did not count the Inuit as Indians, but earlier dictionaries did.

Crocket

Justice Oswald Smith Crocket wrote an opinion briefly concurring with Justices Cannon and Kerwin.

ee also

* List of Supreme Court of Canada cases (Richards Court through Fauteux Court)

External links

* [http://library.usask.ca/native/cnlc/vol05/123.html Full text of the decision]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно решить контрольную?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Eskimos d'Edmonton — Fondé le/en 1949 Siège {{{siège}}} Stade Commonwealth Stadium …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Eskimos and Egypt — was a late 1980s to mid 1990s cross over band based out of Manchester, England. The band was one of the early pioneers of live dance music. The band s members were Paul Cundall on keyboards and synthesizer, David Cameron Pryde on keyboards and… …   Wikipedia

  • Eskĭmos — (Esquimaux, vom Algonkinworte Eskimantick od. Eshkimai, d.i. Rohe Fisch Esser), 1) ursprünglich Name, welchen die Abenakis ihren nördlichen Nachbarn an den Küsten von Labrador beilegten; jetzt 2) allgemeine Bezeichnung eines Volksstammes auf den… …   Pierer's Universal-Lexikon

  • Eskimos — Eskimos, Esquimaux. So heißt eine weit verbreitete, wilde Völkerschaft, welche nomadenartig die eisigen Wüsten von Nordamerika und Grönland bewohnt. Ihr Wuchs steht dem der Europäer bedeutend nach. Die größten ihrer Weiber sind 5 Fuß und die… …   Damen Conversations Lexikon

  • Eskimos — V. esquimau (encycl.) …   Encyclopédie Universelle

  • Eskimos — Eskimo Es ki*mo, n.; pl. {Eskimos}. [Originally applied by the Algonquins to the Northern Indians, and meaning eaters of raw flesh.] (Ethnol.) One of a peculiar race inhabiting Arctic America and Greenland. In many respects the Eskimos resemble… …   The Collaborative International Dictionary of English

  • Eskimos — Pour les articles homonymes, voir Eskimo (homonymie). Eskimos Famille d Eskimos (Inupiat?), 1917 …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Edmonton Eskimos — Eskimos d Edmonton Eskimos d Edmonton Fon …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Eskimos — Eskimo ist die umgangssprachliche Sammelbezeichnung für die arktischen Völker im nördlichen Polargebiet. Die heute oft verwendete politisch korrekte Bezeichnung Inuit ist nicht für alle Eskimovölker und Eskimosprachen anwendbar, da der Name Inuit …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Eskimos — ➡ Inuits * * * …   Universalium

  • Eskimos —  is the plural of Eskimo, but the preferred term is Inuit (sing. and pl.) …   Bryson’s dictionary for writers and editors

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”