Mildenhall Treasure

West Row Treasure

240px West Row Treasure in the British Museum
Material	Silver
Created	4th century AD
Discovered	1942
Present location	British Museum

The West Row Treasure is a major hoard of highly decorated Roman silver tableware from the fourth-century AD, found at West Row, near Mildenhall in the English county of Suffolk. It consists of two large serving platters, two small decorated serving plates, a deep fluted bowl, a set of four large decorated bowls, two small decorated bowls, two small pedestalled dishes, a deep flanged bowl with a deep, domed cover, five small round ladles with dolphin-shaped handles, and eight long-handled spoons (cochlearia). The hoard was discovered while ploughing in January 1942 by Gordon Butcher, who removed it from the ground with help from Sydney Ford, for whom he was working at the time. They did not recognise the objects for what they were, and the hoard did not come to the attention of the authorities until 1946. An inquest was held in the summer of that year, when the find was declared Treasure Trove and acquired by the British Museum in London. Many details of the discovery remained uncertain, not least because it took place in wartime. Academic opinion in the mid-20th century was generally reluctant to believe that such fine-quality Roman silver could possibly have been used in Roman Britain, and so there were many imaginative rumours and even doubts that this was a genuine British find at all.^[1] The numerous well documented discoveries of high-quality Roman material in recent decades, including the Hoxne Hoard, have set all such doubts to rest.

History of display and publication

The Mildenhall find was placed on show in its entirety in the British Museum as soon as the necessary registration and conservation work had been completed following its acquisition in 1946, and it has remained a permanent feature of the museum's Romano-British gallery ever since, with occasional loans of some pieces to special exhibitions both within the museum and elsewhere.

John W. Brailsford promptly published the first brief, summary catalogue of the find,^[2] and successive revised editions of this booklet were published in 1955 and 1964. A somewhat fuller, though still brief, study by Kenneth.S. Painter came out in 1977.^[3] (Note that the catalogue numbers in Painter 1977, cited in the descriptions below, correspond with the sequence of Museum registration numbers, 1946.10-1.1–34, established in the original curatorial listing of the objects). The most striking object in the treasure, the Great Dish (see below) has been illustrated and mentioned in countless publications, including a major paper on late Roman "picture plates".^[4] More recently, Richard Hobbs drew the attention of the academic world to the importance of the fictionalised account by Roald Dahl,^[5] and has since addressed the difficult issues surrounding the actual finding.^[6] However, the treasure still awaits full and detailed scholarly publication.

Roald Dahl's story was originally published in the Saturday Evening Post,^[7] and later as "The Mildenhall Treasure" in his short story collection The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar and Six More.^[8] In Dahl's version of events, Ford was fully aware of the significance of the find, but could not bear to part with the treasure. He kept it and restored it in secret, but a piece left out was seen by an unexpected visitor. As a result, Butcher was deprived of the full ex gratia reward made to finders of buried gold or silver, since the find had not been correctly reported to the authorities.

The contents of the hoard

The Great Dish, or Great Plate of Bacchus

The treasure consists of silver tableware of types current in the 4th century, and was probably concealed at some time in that century.^[9] Most of the objects are comparatively large, and all are of very high-quality workmanship.

Platters and dishes

The Great Dish (also known as the Oceanus Dish or as the Neptune Dish, from the face of a sea-god at its centre), which measures 605 mm in diameter and weighs 8256 g, is the outstanding piece. The decoration, which was worked by chasing from the front, is in three concentric zones. In the centre, the head of a marine deity, probably Oceanus, the personification of the ocean, is shown full-face, with seaweed in his hair and dolphins emerging from his beard. This portrait is surrounded by a narrow inner frieze of decoration populated by nereids (sea-nymphs), tritons and other mythical and natural sea-creatures, while the deep outermost zone carries imagery of the Bacchic thiasos, the dancing, music-making and drinking revels of the god Bacchus. More specifically, the triumph of Bacchus over Hercules is depicted. Hercules is shown staggering drunkenly and supported by two helpful satyrs. Bacchus himself appears with his panther and Silenus at the '12 o'clock' position on the circle in relation to the orientation of the Oceanus head, so that in most illustrations of the dish, he is seen upside-down at the top of the picture. The god Pan also appears in the composition, dancing and brandishing his pan-pipes, as do several dancing Maenads, the female devotees of Bacchus, and satyrs. The entire design is traditionally pagan, and is superbly executed.

One of a pair of silver dishes from the Mildenhall Treasure, decorated with figures of Pan, a nymph and other mythological creatures

Two small plates (respectively 188 and 185 mm in diameter; weights 539 and 613 g.)^[10] are decorated in precisely the same style as the Great Dish: one shows the god Pan, playing his pipes, and a maenad playing the double flute, and the other shows a dancing satyr with a dancing maenad. Both of these small dishes have scratched graffiti in Greek on their undersides: eutheriou, meaning '(property) of Eutherios'. Both also have a bold beaded edging, as does the Great Dish itself and several other items in the assemblage.

Another large, flat serving platter is almost as big as the Great Dish, with a diameter of 556 mm, but is decorated in a very different and more restrained style, consisting of linear geometric decoration inlaid with contrasting black niello (silver sulphide) to form a wide rim border and a circular central panel.

Bowls

A deep fluted bowl with two small swing handles (which were detached at the time of discovery, because solder tends to loosen during burial) is of a type found in several late-Roman silver hoards, such as those in the Esquiline Treasure from Rome, and from Traprain Law in Scotland.^[11][12] The type is thought to have developed from earlier shell-shaped bowls, and to have been used to contain water at the dining table, intended for rinsing the hands of the diners. The chased geometric design in the centre of the Mildenhall fluted bowl^[13] depicts a six-pointed star, a device that had no specific symbolic meaning in the Roman period, but was simply one of many popular geometric figures.

The covered bowl^[14] is a vessel of particular interest. The bowl itself is the earliest object in the hoard, and the only one whose general area of manufacture within the Roman Empire is known for certain. It belongs to a type that is known to have been manufactured in Gaul in the 3rd century AD.^[15] It has a narrow horizontal flange set below the upright rim and decorated with scroll patterns inlaid in niello, and a small nielloed rosette within the centre base. It has been provided with a high, domed lid that fits neatly over the vertical rim and has been decorated in a very different style, with two friezes of low-relief decoration. The upper zone consists of conventional foliate ornament, while the lower is a scene of centaurs attacking various wild animals, separated by Bacchic masks. The small raised rim at the top of the lid would have sufficed for handling it, but set within it is a 'knob' in the form of a silver-gilt statuette of a young, seated triton blowing a conch shell. This figure may well be a secondary addition to the lid, and the lid, in 4th-century style, is certainly a secondary addition to the bowl.

A set of four bowls with wide, horizontal rims^[16] represent a later development of the flanged bowl form. The rims, or flanges, are edged with large beads, and have low-relief decoration that once more follows the traditional pagan, Bacchic theme, with pastoral scenes, numerous animals, natural and mythical, and Bacchic masks. They also have circular medallions of figural decoration within the bowl. One (no.5) has a scene showing a hunter attacking a bear. This bowl, with a diameter of 300 mm, is a little larger than the other three, which all have a diameter of 268 mm and central medallions depicting single heads in profile; a young woman, a veiled matron, and a helmeted head. The identification of these remains uncertain.

There is a matching pair of smaller flanged bowls,^[17] (diameter 168 mm): they are intricately decorated with beading, foliate scrolls and small birds and hares on the rims, and have rosettes in relief in the centre base. The main bodies of these little bowls has a delicate fluted pattern internally.

Pedestalled dishes

Two pedestalled dishes also form a pair.^[18] They were originally thought to be stemmed cups with wide, flat bases, somewhat like a modern wineglass in shape, but the foliate pattern on the 'bases' and the relatively unfinished interiors of the 'cups' show that they were used the other way up, as small (115mm diameter) flat dishes on a stem with a bowl-shaped base. Vessels of the same shape occur in the Traprain Law treasure, found in 1919.^[19]

Spoons

The remaining objects in the Mildenhall assemblage are all small eating utensils; five round-bowled ladles or spoons, and eight long-handled spoons of the common late-Roman cochlear type. The round 'ladles' have zoomorphic handles cast in the form of dolphins. There is a comparable piece in the Traprain treasure,^[20] and there are two sets each of ten ladles of this type, though not with zoomorphic handles, in the Hoxne hoard.^[21] Only four handles survive from the Mildenhall ladles, and one of those is broken and incomplete. Because handles and bowls were soldered together in antiquity and had separated during burial, it is not certain which handle belongs to which bowl. In theory, if each component bowl and each handle were from a different utensil, there could have been as many as 9 ladles originally. In practice, it seems more likely that the handles and bowls present all belong together, and the group has therefore been reconstructed as five ladles, combining the existing handles and bowls.

The 8 cochlearia belong to three groups or sets. Three^[22] have pear-shaped bowls with foliate decoration within. Nos. 29-31 are all inscribed within the bowls with the only explicitly Christian references in the group, namely the standard Christian Chi-rho monogram, flanked by the latters alpha and omega. The other two spoons, nos. 27 and 28, have bowl inscriptions with personal names: PASCENTIAVIVAS and PAPITTEDOVIVAS. Though vivas (may you live!) inscriptions are not overtly or exclusively Christian, they are quite commonly seen in Christian contexts, so these spoons may also allude to Christian belief.

Inscriptions

In addition to the three definite Christian symbols and two possibly Christian inscriptions on the spoons, and the ownership graffiti of Eutherios on the two small Bacchic platters, several of the Mildenhall pieces, in common with many large items of Roman silver tableware from other finds, bear weight-inscriptions. These are scratched in inconspicuous places, such as bases, and can be very difficult to read and interpret, since they do not necessarily record the weight of the object itself, but sometimes of a set of which that object forms part. Although domestic silver was used for social display, so that its artistic quality was important to the owner, the actual bullion value of precious metal was part of his wealth, and needed to be noted and recorded.

Importance

The Mildenhall treasure contains pieces that undoubtedly belong to the first rank of Roman art and craftsmanship on an international scale of excellence. Although it was found at a time, and in a manner, that leave many unanswered questions about the reasons for and date of its concealment, the overall 4th-century dating is certain, and the decoration, with its traditional pagan themes just touched with the influence of the new faith, Christianity, in some of the minor pieces, is characteristic of that period of change in the Roman Empire. We cannot yet say where objects such as the Great Dish were manufactured, but it seems safe to surmise that it would have been somewhere in the general Mediterranean region.

The rate of discovery of metal hoards of all periods has accelerated in Britain since the middle of the 20th century, due to a combination of circumstances that include changing agricultural practices, the rise of metal-detecting as a hobby, and better public understanding of archaeology. The Mildenhall group is exceptional by any standards, but in 1946, it still seemed 'far too good' to be a British find.

Older finds, such as the treasures from Traprain Law^[23] and the Esquiline Hill in Rome,^[24] and more recent ones, such as the great Kaiseraugst treasure from Switzerland^[25] and the Hoxne hoard,^[26] can now been seen in both international and Romano-British contexts that make it clear that personal possessions of very high quality were indeed in use in the frontier province of Britain in the 4th century AD, and that the Mildenhall material remains pre-eminent as a partial set of silver tableware of that period.

The hoard was number 7 in the list of British archaeological finds selected by experts at the British Museum for the 2003 BBC Television documentary Our Top Ten Treasures presented by Adam Hart-Davis.

Controversy

While the majority of scholars support the identification and dating of the objects, and their association with the Mildenhall site, some scholars, at times, have argued that the Mildenhall Treasure may be misdated, or may not truly belong to the Mildenhall site. They argue that the pieces do not properly resemble the style and quality of work expected to be found in provincial Roman Britain, and that since none of the pieces show damage from having been "discovered" with a plough or shovel, there is the possibility that it was not in fact buried at Mildenhall all these centuries, and rather came from somewhere else. Some have suggested the pieces were looted from sites in Italy during World War II, brought back to England and re-buried so as to stage a "discovery," though most scholars put little stake in that theory, and abide by the standard story that the objects were hidden by fleeing Romans who intended to come back for it at a later date and never did.^[27]

See also

• Berthouville Treasure
• List of hoards in Britain

References

1. ^ Richard Hobbs, 'The Secret History of the Mildenhall Treasure', Antiquaries Journal 88 (2008), pp.376-420
2. ^ J.W. Brailsford, The Mildenhall Treasure, a provisional handbook, London 1947
3. ^ K.S. Painter, The Mildenhall Treasure, Roman Silver from East Anglia, London 1977
4. ^ J.M.C. Toynbee & K.S. Painter, 'Silver Picture Plates from Late Antiquity: AD 300 to 700', Archaeologia 108 (1986), pp.15-65
5. ^ Richard Hobbs, 'The Mildenhall Treasure: Roald Dahl's ultimate tale of the unexpected', Antiquity 71 (1997), pp.63-73
6. ^ Hobbs 2008
7. ^ Dahl, Roald (1947). "The Mildenhall Treasure" in Saturday Evening Post (20 September): 20-21, 93-4, 96-7, 99.
8. ^ Dahl, Roald (1995). The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar and Six More (5th edition ed.). London: Penguin Group. pp. 215. ISBN 0-14-037348-9. 
9. ^ "The Mildenhall Treasure". Mildenhall Museum. http://www.mildenhallmuseum.co.uk/Treasure.htm. Retrieved May 4, 2006. 
10. ^ Painter 1977, nos. 2 and 3
11. ^ Kathleen J. Shelton, The Esquiline Treasure, London 1981
12. ^ Alexander O. Curle, The Treasure of Traprain, Glasgow 1923
13. ^ Painter 1977, no.15-17
14. ^ Painter 1977, nos.11-12
15. ^ F. Baratte, La vaisselle d'argent en Gaule dans l'antiquité tardive (1993), pp. 60-64
16. ^ Painter 1977, nos. 5–8
17. ^ Painter 1977, nos.9 and 10
18. ^ Painter 1977, nos.13, 14
19. ^ Curle 1923, pp.28-9
20. ^ Curle 1923, pp.70-71
21. ^ Catherine Johns, The Hoxne Late Roman Treasure, London 2010, catalogue numbers 42 - 61
22. ^ Painter 1977, nos. 32-4
23. ^ Curle 1923
24. ^ Shelton 1981
25. ^ H.A. Cahn & A. Kaufmann-Heinimann (eds.), Der spätrömische Silberschatz von Kaiseraugst, (Derendingen 1984), and Martin A. Guggisberg & Annemarie Kaufmann-Heinimann (eds.), Der spätrömische Silberschatz von Kaiseraugst, die neuen Funde: Silber im Spannungsfeld von Geschichte, Politik und Gesellschaft der Spätantike (August 2003)
26. ^ P.S.W. Guest, The Late Roman Gold and Silver Coins from the Hoxne Treasure, (London 2005) and Catherine Johns, The Hoxne Late Roman Treasure; Gold jewellery and silver plate, (London 2010)
27. ^ Stokstad, Marilyn and Michael Cothren. Art History 4th Edition. Pearson Prentice Hall, 2011. p214.

External links

• The Mildenhall Treasure
• "Age of Conquest". David Dimbleby. Seven Ages of Britain. BBC 1. 15:10 minutes in. Retrieved on 21 Nov 201.