Reasonable and Non Discriminatory Licensing


Reasonable and Non Discriminatory Licensing

Reasonable and Non Discriminatory Licensing (RAND) is a term for a type of licensing typically used during standardization processes. The normal case is that when joining the standardization body, companies agree that if they receive any patents on technologies which become essential to the standard then they agree to allow other groups attempting to implement the standard to use those patents and they agree that the charges for those patents shall be "reasonable". RAND licenses allow a competitive market to develop between multiple companies making products which implement a standard.

Having created a RAND based standard does mean that the known exclusive rights can be licensed from their right holders at published RAND conditions. If at a later time exclusive rights beyond this will get visible or even claimed, this does not at all mean that those parts will be available under RAND conditions but the requested charges can be rather "unreasonable" instead. The acting standardisation group often has few options for reacting to this, other than creating a newer version of the standard that works around the parts now known to be problematic (if this is possible at all). For example, see the case of the "de facto" GIF standard or the JPEG standard, which was severely damaged by suddenly surfacing patents.

The second, more subtle, limitation of RAND licenses in standardisation is that the term does not say anything about the relation of the license to the product cost. With this a right that was found to fit, e.g. into a medical device, can have a rather high price per unit via its published RAND conditions. Now finding a second case, e.g. in a cheap consumer device, will not necessarily change the RAND licensing terms in any way.

RAND is also in conflict with free software as this is often offered for no fee at all and most often with no way to track any distribution or even the "customer base". Whoever does use the software is granted the rights of the copyright holders for the code via some license like the GPL for free. Other rights like patent rights and similar are generally not covered with this. If a user of such software thinks he needs more rights from third parties, then he has to care for this on his own. A RAND licensing for such other rights might still ease his operations but it just negates the freeness of a particular piece of software — written and licensed free but still in need for charges. Providing really free software for a standard that incorporates RAND components therefore is a problem for the free and open source community.

One very successful area where RAND is in use is in the GSM and UMTS mobile phone standards where many different manufacturers compete to provide handsets and base stations. This is possible because the systems are based on open standards and because the patents required to implement this are mostly available under RAND terms. This situation is claimed, for example by the 3GPP to lead to strong price competition and lower market prices for this equipment both to consumers and to operators. This compares very well to other standards such as CDMA, where single companies may have almost complete control over particular areas of technology and manufacturing.

In contrast to the situation for GSM, the World Wide Web Consortium considered standardising on RAND principles, but, after considerable resistance from many different sources, abandoned this strategy in order to aim for royalty free licensing.

As the word "reasonable" is absolutely free in interpretation, standards of the RAND type can be used to keep small and mid-sized businesses away from the market. This can easily lead to oligopolies, where few big enterprises share the markets. Customers then have to pay inflated prices and technological and economical progress is decelerated.

ee also

* Fair, Reasonable and Non Discriminatory Licensing (FRAND)

External links

* [http://www.3gpatents.com/ 3G Patents Ltd — Licensing body for WCDMA patents]
* [http://www.w3.org/TR/patent-practice Current W3C patent policy]
* [http://lpf.ai.mit.edu/ League for Programming Freedom]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Fair, Reasonable and Non Discriminatory terms — Standard setting organizations commonly have rules that govern the ownership of patent rights that cover the standards the adopt. One of the most common rules is that a patent covering the standard must be adopted on reasonable and… …   Wikipedia

  • Comparison of Office Open XML and OpenDocument — This is a comparison of the Office Open XML document file format with the OpenDocument file format. Contents 1 Comparison 2 See also 3 References 4 External …   Wikipedia

  • Cross-licensing — A cross licensing agreement is a contract between two or more parties where each party grants rights to their intellectual property to the other parties. Contents 1 Patent law 2 Non patent law 3 See also 4 …   Wikipedia

  • Computers and Information Systems — ▪ 2009 Introduction Smartphone: The New Computer.       The market for the smartphone in reality a handheld computer for Web browsing, e mail, music, and video that was integrated with a cellular telephone continued to grow in 2008. According to… …   Universalium

  • Glossary of patent legal concepts — Patent law (patents for inventions) …   Wikipedia

  • Common Address Redundancy Protocol — The Common Address Redundancy Protocol or CARP is a protocol which allows multiple hosts on the same local network to share a set of IP addresses. Its primary purpose is to provide failover redundancy, especially when used with firewalls and… …   Wikipedia

  • C Sharp (programming language) — The correct title of this article is C# (programming language). The substitution or omission of the # sign is because of technical restrictions. C# Paradigm(s) multi paradigm: structured, imperative …   Wikipedia

  • RAND (Lizenzierung) — Achtung: Die englische Fassung von der dieser Artikel abgeleitet wurde ist umstritten entferne diesen Hinweis wenn der Artikel ausreichend überarbeitet wurde. Als fair und diskriminierungsfrei (Reasonable and Non Discriminatory Licensing, RAND)… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Smartphone — Modern smartphones. A smartphone is a high end mobile phone[1][2] …   Wikipedia

  • Rand — may refer to a number of places, people, organizations, and acronyms:Places* Rand, New South Wales, a small town in Australia * Rand, Lincolnshire, a small village in Lincolnshire, England * Rand, Colorado, a small unincorporated community in… …   Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.