Baker v. Willoughby

Baker v. Willoughby

"Baker v. Willoughby" [1969] 3 All ER 1528 was a House of Lords case decision on causation in the law of torts, notable for its idiosyncratic facts. The case is concerned with the question of "breaking the chain of causation", or "novus actus interveniens".

Facts

Mr Baker (the plaintiff) was knocked down by the defendant's car, leaving him with a stiff ankle of his left leg and reduced mobility and income. After the accident but before the trial, Mr Baker was shot by a robber in his injured leg and the leg had to be amputated.

Judgment

The defendant argued that the injuries he had caused to Mr Baker were obviated by the later accident. His argument was based on causation: the shooting was an intervening event, which was not caused by his negligent driving and the amputation of the man's leg meant that the defendant could not be held accountable for any loss, since the damage he had done previously no longer existed.

The House of Lords has unanimously rejected this argument. Per Lord Pearson, although this argument seemed to make logical sense, it would produce a "manifest injustice" if it were allowed to succeed. Lord Reid considered that the damage caused by the defendant - the plaintiff's inability to run, his reduced working capacities etc. - were not obviated by the shooter's act. Furthermore, if the shooter (who could not be found), were to be held liable, he would only have to pay the losses he caused Mr Baker by the shooting, not by the earlier car accident (because of the rule that "the defendant must take the plaintiff as he finds him"). Consequently, Mr Baker would remain undercompensated.

Later case law

The correctness of this judgement and its value as precedent was later questioned by the House of Lords in "Jobling v. Associated Dairies Ltd" [1981] 2 All ER 752

ee also

* Causation
* Breaking the chain


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужна курсовая?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Breaking the chain — English Tort law Part of the common law series Negligence Duty of care Bolam test Breach of duty Causation …   Wikipedia

  • Colin Pearson, Baron Pearson — Rt. Hon. Baron Pearson Colin Hargreaves Pearson, Baron Pearson PC, KC, CBE (28 July 1899 – 31 January 1980) was a Canadian born English barrister and judge. Rising to sit as a judge in the House of Lords, he is best remembered for his… …   Wikipedia

  • 1976 NSWRFL season — Teams 12 Premiers Manly Warringah (3rd title) Minor premiers …   Wikipedia

  • Douglas MacArthur — General MacArthur redirects here. For other uses, see General MacArthur (disambiguation). For the diplomat, see Douglas MacArthur II. Douglas MacArthur …   Wikipedia

  • Moose Jaw City — was a provincial electoral district in the Canadian province of Saskatchewan. This constituency existed from 1905 to 1967 when it was divided into Moose Jaw North and Moose Jaw South (Wakamow). It was the riding of Opposition leader Wellington… …   Wikipedia

  • Spilsby — Infobox UK place official name= Spilsby country= England region= East Midlands population= 2,336 (Parish) os grid reference= TF4066 latitude= 53.17270 longitude= 0.09310 post town= SPILSBY postcode area= PE postcode district= PE23 dial code=… …   Wikipedia

  • Saison 6 de Chapeau melon et bottes de cuir (première série) — Article détaillé présentant les épisodes[1] de la sixième saison (1968 1969), en couleurs, de la série télévisée britannique Chapeau melon et bottes de cuir, première série (The Avengers). Sommaire 1 Données communes à tous les épisodes …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Saison 6 de Chapeau melon et bottes de cuir (1961) — Article détaillé présentant les épisodes[1] de la sixième saison (1968 1969), en couleurs, de la série télévisée britannique Chapeau melon et bottes de cuir, première série (The Avengers). Sommaire 1 Données communes à tous les épisodes …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Metrobus (Sydney) — Metrobus Mode Bus rapid transit Owner Ministry of Transport …   Wikipedia

  • Silent Hill 2 — У этого термина существуют и другие значения, см. Silent Hill. Silent Hill 2 Североамериканская обложка игры с изображением Анжелы Ороско и логотипа проекта …   Википедия

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”