Entomotoxicology

In forensic entomology, entomotoxicology is the analysis of toxins in arthropods (mainly flies and beetles) that feed on carrion. Using arthropods in a corpse or at a crime scene, investigators can determine whether toxins were present in a body at the time of death. This technique is a major advance in forensics; previously, such determinations were impossible in the case of severely decomposed bodies devoid of intoxicated tissue and bodily fluids. Ongoing research into the effects of toxins on arthropod development has also allowed better estimations of postmortem intervals.

Techniques

ample preparation

Entomological samples are analyzed in similar standards to human tissue samples. Once the specimens have been removed from the body, or the crime scene, they are washed with deionized or tap water. The specimens are then frozen for storage at a temperature ranging from -20°C to 4°C until they are needed for analyses. Gagliano-Candela, R. and Aventaggiato, L. “The detection of toxic substances in entomological specimens.” "International Journal of Legal Medicine" 114 (2001): 197-203.] Specimens are prepared for analysis in a variety of ways. They differ based upon the substance that is in question.

To prepare for analysis of inorganic substances, the arthropods are taken out of storage, washed, and then dried to insure the removal of any foreign human fluids. The arthropods are then crushed and stored in a porcelain crucible at a constant 650°C for 24 hours. The resulting ash has a high concentration of metals, which are then analyzed by acid digestion using 70% HNO₃ (nitric acid).

For preparation of organic substances, the specimens are first washed and dried. Between 1-10 grams of larvae are finely cut and an internal standard solution is added. The specimens are then homogenized, in a 0.9% saline solution, and centrifuged. Chitinous samples of organic substances are prepared by adding an internal standard solution to finely chopped puparial casings and placing the sample in test tubes. Strong acids or bases break down the chitonous exoskeleton to release any toxins. Hydrochloric acid is added to the test tube, and the sample is allowed to extract overnight at a temperature of 65°C. The acid solution is then removed and the organic substances are fully available for further analyses.

Analysis

Analytical techniques differ for organic and inorganic substances. Inorganic substances are analyzed using inductively coupled plasma (ICP), atomic emission spectroscopy (AES), and flame atomic absorption spectrometry (FAAS). ICP is primarily used when the concentration of the substance is relatively low. Organic substances are analyzed by the screening test, radioimmunoassay (RIA), and by confirmation tests which include chromatography techniques including thin layer chromatography and gas chromatography. Liquid-liquid extraction (LLE) and solid phase extraction (SPE) are the analytical techniques of choice when dealing with substances in an aqueous phase.

Effects of toxins on arthropods

Drugs can have a variety of effects on development rates of arthropods. Morphine, heroin, cocaine, and methamphetamine are commonly involved in cases where forensic entomology is used. The stages of growth for insects provides a basis for determining a cause in altered cycles in a specific species. An altered stage in development can often indicate toxins in the carrion on which the insects are feeding. Beetles (Order: Coleoptera) and beetle feces are often used in entomotoxicology, but the presence of toxins is often the result of the beetles’ feeding on fly larvae that have been feeding on the carrion containing toxic substances. Flies (Order: Diptera) are the most commonly used insect in entomotoxicology.

Through the study of "Sarcophaga (Curranea) tibialis" larvae, barbiturates were found to increase the length of the larval stage of the fly, which will ultimately cause an increase in the time it takes to reach the stage of pupation.Musvasva, E. and others. “Preliminary observations of the effects of hydrocortisone and sodium methohexital on development of Sarcophaga (Curranea) tibialis Macquart (Diptera: Sarcophagidae), and implications for estimating post mortem interval.” "Forensic Science International" 120 (2001): 37-41.] Morphine and heroin were both believed to slow down the rate of fly development.Introna, Francesco and others. ”Entomotoxicology.” "Forensic Science International" 120 (2001): 42-47.] [Carvalho, Lucila M.L.; Linhares, Arício X.; and Trigo, José Roberto. “Determination of drug levels and effect of diazepam on the growth of necrophagous flies of forensic importance in southeastern Brazil.” "Forensic Science International" 120 (2001): 140-144.] However, closer examination of the effects of heroin on fly development has shown that it actually speeds up larval growth and then decreases the development rate of the pupal stage. This actually increases the overall timing of development from egg to adult. Research of "Lucilia sericata" (Diptera: Calliphoridae), reared on various concentrations of morphine injected meat, found higher concentrations of morphine in shed pupal casings than in adults. [ Bourel, Benoit and others. “Morphine extraction in necrophagous insects remains for determining ante-mortem opiate intoxication.” "Forensic Science International" 120 (2001): 127-131.] Cocaine and methamphetamine also accelerate the rate of fly development.

Some effects depend on the concentration of the toxin while others simply depend on its presence. For example, cocaine (at the lethal dose) causes larvae to “develop more rapidly 36 (to 76) hours after hatching”. The amount of growth depends on the concentration of cocaine in the area being fed upon. The amount of methamphetamine, on the other hand, affects the rate of pupal development. A lethal dose of methamphetamine increases larval development through approximately the first two days and afterwards the rate drops if exposure remains at the median lethal dosage. The presence of methamphetamine was also found to cause a decrease in the maximum length of the larvae.

Along with changes in development rates, extended periods of insect feeding refrain and variation in the size of the insect during any stage of development, can also indicate the presence of toxic substances in the insect’s food source.

Examples of use

Since J.C. Beyer and his partners first demonstrated the ability of toxins to be recovered from maggots feeding on human remains in 1980, the use of entomotoxicology in investigations has made an emergence into the field of forensic entomology.Pounder, Derrick J. “Forensic entomo-toxicology.” "Journal of the Forensic Science Society" 31 (1991): 469-472.] An example of one such case involved the discovery of a 22 year old female with a history of suicide attempts found 14 days after her death. Due to the body’s advanced stage of decomposition, no organ or tissue samples were viable to screen for toxins. Through gas chromatography (GC) and thin-layer chromatography (TLC) analysis of "Cochliomyia macellaria" (Diptera: Calliphoridae) larvae found feeding on the woman’s body, phenobarbital was detected and perceived to have been in the woman’s system upon death.

Drug abuse detected

In France, Pascal Kintz and his colleagues were able to demonstrate the use of entomotoxicology to detect toxins that were not discovered during the analysis of body tissues and fluids of a body found roughly two months after death. A liquid chromatography analysis on organ tissue and Calliphoridae larvae found at the scene revealed the existence of five prescription medications. Triazolam, however, was only detected in the analysis of maggots and not in organ tissue samples. Comparative research showed increased sensitivity of toxicological analysis of Diptera samples over decomposed body tissues. A similar case involved the discovery of the remains of a 29 year old known to abuse drugs, last seen alive five months prior. Through the use of GC and GC-MS techniques, Nolte and his partners discovered the presence of cocaine in decomposed muscle tissue and in maggots found on the body. However, due to the severity of decomposition of the muscle tissue, more suitable drug samples (devoid of decomposition byproducts) were reared from the maggots.

Aid determination of origin

Pekka Nuorteva presented the case of a young woman found severely decomposed in Inkoo, Finland. Diptera larvae recovered from the body were reared to adulthood and found to contain low levels of mercury, indicating that the woman came from an area of comparatively low mercury pollution. This assumption was proven correct once the woman was identified and found to have been a student in Turku, Finland. This case demonstrated the ability of toxicological analysis to help determine origin. Goff, M. Lee and Lord, Wayne D. “Entomotoxicology- A New Area for Forensic Investigation.” "The American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology" 15 (1994): 51-57.] This case applied Nuorteva’s research involving mercury and its affect on maggots. Through experimentation, it was determined that maggots (fed on fish containing mercury) possessed levels of mercury in their tissue of even greater concentration than in the tissue of the fish. Nuorteva also discovered that the presence of mercury in the maggots systems hindered their ability to enter into the pupal stage.Goff, M. Lee. A Fly for the Prosecution. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2000.]

Toxin confounding of postmortem interval estimate

Through the analysis of specific cases, it was revealed that toxins present in a person’s body upon death can confound postmortem interval estimations. An example of such a case, reported by Gunatilake and Goff, concerned the discovery of a 58 year old male with a history of attempted suicides found dead in a crawl space in Honolulu, Hawaii last seen eight days prior. Two species of Diptera (Calliphoridae), "Chrysomya megacephala" and "Chrysomya rufifacies", found on the corpse and tissue samples from the body revealed malathion. Investigators found it abnormal that, given the conditions, there were only two fly species found on the body and that these species revealed a postmortem interval of five days. Thus it was determined that the presence of the organophosphate malathion in the man’s system delayed oviposition for a few days.

Paul Catts analyzed a case in Spokane, Washington where maggots rendered differing postmortem estimations. A 20 year old female victim was found stabbed to death and laying in an open environment surrounded by trees. Most of the oldest maggots found on the body were approximately 6-7 mm long which suggested that they were roughly seven days old. There was, however, a very strange exception which was the retrieval of a 17.7 mm maggot which suggested an age of 3 weeks. After ruling out the possibility that the maggot had traveled onto the corpse from carrion nearby, it was assumed that there was no conceivable way a 3 week old maggot could have been present on the corpse. Later investigations revealed that the woman had snorted cocaine shortly before her death and that the 17.7 mm maggot must have feed in the woman’s nasal cavity. Research revealed that maggot development can be sped up by the ingestion of cocaine. [ Catts, E. Paul, and Neal H. Haskell. Entomology and Death: A Procedural Guide. Clemson: Joyce’s Print Shop, Inc., 1990.]

Use of shed casings and insect feces

Not only are tissues from maggots used to detect toxins, shed casings and insect feces have also been used to detect and identify toxins present in corpses upon death. An instance of this finding was demonstrated by Edward McDonough, a medical examiner in Connecticut. A mummified corpse of a middle-aged woman was found inside of her home. Prescription medicine bottles were found with labels identifying the following drugs: ampicillin, Ceclor, doxycyline, erythromycin, Elavil, Lomotil, pentazocine, and Tylenol 3. McDonough performed toxicological analyses on stomach contents and dried sections of brain and found lethal levels of amitriptyline and nortriptyline. Insect feces, shed pupal cases of "Megaselia scalaris" (Diptera: Phoridae), and shed larval skins of "Dermestes maculates" (Coleoptera: Dermestidae) were gathered from the corpse at the scene. McDonough sent these to an FBI lab which broke down the complex structures of the samples using strong acids and bases and freed the toxins for analysis. The cast pupal cases and larval skins were also found to contain amitriptyline and nortriptyline. Larger concentrations were discovered in the pupal cases because phorid flies prefer to feed on softer tissues. The hide beetle larval skins revealed lower concentrations of the drugs because these beetles prefer to feed on dry, mummified bodies. The use of pupal cases and larval skins allows for investigators to detect toxins in a body years after death.

Limitations

Further research should be conducted in order to fill the gaps in entomotoxicology. Such areas as bioaccumulation, insect metabolism of drugs, and quantitative analyses of insect evidence have only begun to be researched. Because it is a relatively new branch of forensic entomology, entomotoxicology has its limitations. According to Pounder’s research, there is no correlation between the drug concentration in tissue and the larvae feeding on that tissue. Entomological specimens make for excellent qualitative toxicological specimens. There is, however, a lack of research in the way of developing an assessment that can quantify the concentration of a drug in tissue using entomological evidence. One reason for this is that a drug can only be detected in larvae when the rate of absorption exceeds the rate of elimination. [Wilson, Z.; Hubbard, S.; Pounder, D.J. “Drug analysis in fly larvae.” "The American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology" 14 (1993): 118-120.] demonstrated this theory using "Calliphora vicina" larvae reared on human skeletal muscle obtained from cases of co-proxamol and amitriptyline overdose. Samples of pupae and third instar larvae no longer contained concentrations of the drugs, suggesting that drugs do not bioaccumulate over the entire life-cycle of larvae. This leads entomologists to theorize that toxins are eliminated from the larvae’s system over time if they are not receiving a constant supply of the toxin.

References