Stan Reid

Infobox afl player | firstname = Stan
lastname = Reid




birthdate = 12 July 1872
birthplace =
Swan Hill, Victoria
originalteam = Fitzroy Football Club (VFA)
heightweight =
dead =
deathdate = Death date and age|1901|6|23|1872|7|12
deathplace = Middel-Kraal,
South Africa,
The Anglo-Boer War
debutdate = 29 May 1897
debutteam =
Fitzroy
debutopponent = Essendon
debutstadium =
Brunswick Street Oval
playingteams = Fitzroy (1897-1898)
* 24 games, 8 goals
coach =
coachingteams =
statsend = 1898
careerhighlights =

Stanley Simpson Reid (12 July 1872 - 23 June 1901) was an Australian rules footballer with the Fitzroy Football Club from 1891-1898, an ordained minister of the Presbyterian Church, and a member of the Imperial Forces in the Anglo-Boer War, firstly as a trooper in the Second Western Australian (Mounted Infantry) Contingent (2WAMI) in 1900, and then as commissioned officer in the Sixth Western Australian (Mounted Infantry) Contingent (6WAMI) in 1901. [ [http://www.bwm.org.au/site/Units.asp Royal Australian Armoured Corps Association: Australian and Colonial Units of the Boer War] ]

He died in active service in the Anglo-Boer War.

Early life

Stanley Simpson Reid was the second child of Rev. John Bentley Reid (1843-?) and Sibyl Rose Reid, née Drury (1849-1943). [Sibyl's family name sometimes appears as "Drewry".]

The Reids had arrived in Australia in 1871 on the "Hampshire", and moved straight to Swan Hill, Victoria where Rev. John Reid became its first Presbyterian minister. He was ordained as soon as Swan Hill's first Presbyterian Church, "The John Knox Church", was completed in December 1872. [ [http://www.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~ausshghs/archive_2001/arch_news3_May2001.htm Swan Hill Genealogical and Historical Society: Swan Hill at the time of Federation] .]

After spending some time in Victoria Rev. John Bentley Reid moved to Western Australia. He was the joint minister of both the Leederville and the Subiaco Presbyterian churches in 1899. ["The West Australian", 30 September 1899.]

Stan was born in Swan Hill, Victoria on 12 July, 1872. [The Reid's six children were Reginald Bentley Reid (born 1871), Stanley Spencer Reid (1872), Francis Bentley Reid (1874), John Cecil Drury Reid (1876-1917) — who worked as a surveyor in the early days of Canberra and the Federal Capital Territory, [http://www.tams.act.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0015/13182/426.pdf Heritage Objects Register Citation (page 6)] , who won the Military Cross, [http://www.awm.gov.au/cms_images/awm28/1/204P2/0059.pdf Recommendation for John Cecil Drury Reid to be awarded a Military Cross] and who died of wounds sustained in action in World War I, [http://www.awm.gov.au/roh/person.asp?p=145-46195 Australian War Memorial Honour Roll: Lieutenant John Cecil Drury Reid MC] — Winifred Mona Reid (1885), and William Brenmer (sic) Reid (1887). [http://archiver.rootsweb.ancestry.com/th/read/GENANZ/2005-08/1123340574 Rootsweb Item: John Bentley Reid and Sibyl Rose Drewry] ]

Education

He attended Caulfield Grammar School, Scotch College, the University of Melbourne, and Ormond College. [Main & Allen, D., (2002), p.7; Webber (1981, p.311) has the following in his Register of Students 1881-1981: "Reid, S.S. 1886—?".]

He graduated from Melbourne University with a Bachelor of Arts in 1896.Main & Allen, D., (2002), p.7.]

VFA footballer (1891-1896)

Reid made his debut for the VFA team Fitzroy in 1891, He played quite a number of senior games for Fitzroy whilst the club was in the Victorian Football Association (VFA), and was soon considered to be one of the game's best defenders. [Main & Holmesby (2002).]

VFL footballer (1897-1898)

By the start of 1897, when the Fitzroy Football Club left the VFA and took part in the inaugural VFL competition, Reid was already well established as a defender, and had gained a reputation for his high making and his long kicking.

All told he played 24 senior Victorian Football League (VFL) games; eight in 1897, [ [http://stats.afl.com.au/public/statistics/player_roundbyround/1897/7/player_roundbyround_7_1897.shtml?club_idIndex=5&season_idIndex=110 AFL Player Statistics (Round by Round): Fitzroy Football Club 1897] ] and sixteen in 1898. [ [http://stats.afl.com.au/public/statistics/player_roundbyround/1898/7/player_roundbyround_7_1898.shtml?club_idIndex=5&season_idIndex=109 AFL Player Statistics (Round by Round): Fitzroy Football Club 1898] ]

His last game for Fitzroy was in the 1898 VFL Grand Final, [A photograph of the 1898 premiership side — the Fitzroy players and club officials — is at Holmesby & Main (1996, p.16). Stan Reid appears at second from the left in the third row from the front.] in which he was one of Fitzroy's best players. [Atkinson, (2002).]

VFL representative footballer (1897)

In 1897, the VFL arranged a match between a combined VFL team and a combined Ballarat Football Association team. [In 1897, with the VFA shattered by the defection of the eight VFL teams, the Ballarat competition was one of the strongest in Australia outside of the VFL.]

Stan Reid played for the combined Victorian Football League side, in the VFL's first ever representative match.

The match was scheduled to take place at the Melbourne Cricket Ground on Monday 12 July; however, an apparent problem with Melbourne Cricket Club allowing the VFL to use its pavilion facilities, meant that the game was actually played at the Brunswick Street Oval in North Fitzroy. [Ross, (1996), p.38.]

The well trained Ballarat team beat the VFL side — the VFL team had not trained together, and had six last minute replacements in the original selected side — by a score of 13.11 (89) to 8.6 (54). [Ross, (1996), p.39.]

Presbyterian Church

Because Melbourne University was a secular institution in the nineteenth century, it did not offer degrees in Divinity. [It remains a secular institution today; and still does not offer degrees in Divinity.University of Melbourne#History]

Consequently, Reid had to pursue his theological studies at the separate Presbyterian theological college that was situated on the university's campus, Ormond College, graduating at the end of 1898.

He was ordained as the first minister to the newly formed St. George's Presbyterian Church in the Western Australian gold mining town of Boulder on 15 March 1899. ["The West Australian", Saturday, 30 September 1899.]

Military service

Soon after the Second Boer War (The Anglo-Boer War) had broken out in the October of 1899, Reid volunteered to serve as a chaplain to the Second Contingent of the Western Australian Mounted Infantry.

Trooper Reid

Whilst still in Victoria, Reid had served for 18 months ["The West Australian", 29 December 1899: "Stanley Spencer Reid, 27, Victoria, Presbyterian minister. Served eighteen months in Victorian Mounted Rifles."] as a member of the self-funded (the men were required to supply and maintain their own horse, and supply their own uniform, rifle, saddles, harness, and all other equipment), voluntary citizens' military force known as the Victorian Mounted Rifles, and had been trained in various cavalry activities, such as marksmanship and both mounted and dismounted parade drills. [ [http://www.gardencentre.com.au/traralgonhistory/Victorian%20Mounted%20Rifles.htm The Traralgon & District Historical Society] ; [http://www.bwm.org.au/site/VMR.asp The Australian Boer War Memorial: Victorian Mounted Rifles] .]

He eventually enlisted as a private in the Second Western Australian (Mounted Infantry) Contingent (2WAMI) ["The West Australian", Thursday, 28 December 1899 noted that "The Rev. Stanley Reid, Presbyterian minister at Boulder, has been accepted as a member of the Western Australian contingent."] which left Australia on 3 February, 1900. [Main & Allen, D., (2002), p.8. [http://www.awm.gov.au/nominalrolls/boer/person.asp?p=13380 Boer War Nominal Roll: Stanley Spencer Reid (41)] ]

He was a popular soldier and he was well-respected for his military skills by his fellow troopers. ["The West Australian" of 20 January 1900, notes that Reid's response to a toast made to the "Scottish Members of the Second Contingent" (thirty of whom were present at the "Smoke Night") was "greeted with uproarious cheers"; note that Reid was asked to respond despite being "merely" a Trooper. The newspaper was also led to remark that "it might seem to [those assembled at the Send-Off] that a clergyman should volunteer for active service, and [Reid] would say at once that, though he had not received the sympathy which he had expected from the members of his own denomination, he knew in his heart that he had the sympathy of those who were around him then."] .

The contingent (consisting of 6 officers, 97 other ranks, 125 horses, one spring cart, and one wagon [Burridge, (1972), p.10.] ) left Australia on the "S.S. Surrey" on 3 February 1900. Immediately the West Australian contingent arrived in South Africa it was attached to the 11th Division of the South Africa Field Force, commanded by Lieutenant-General Reginald Pole-Carew. On 25 July 1900, as the division began its advance to Komati Poort on the Komati River, at the frontier between Mozambique and South Africa, Reid became separated from his Division, and was listed as "missing" for twelve days. He rejoined his Division at Middelburg. The Division eventually reached Komati Poort on 24 September.

During this first tour of duty, Reid had seen action in Johannesburg, Diamond Hill, Belfast, Cape Colony, and Orange Free State. [Burridge (1972), p.14.]

Arrest and repatriation to Australia

During this time Reid had written a letter to someone in Australia in which he was highly critical of an officer. A West Australian newspaper had obtained the letter and published it without seeking Reid's permission to do so. As soon as the military authorities in South Africa became aware of the letter's publication, Reid was arrested and repatriated to Australia (he reached Fremantle, along with the rest of the Second Western Australian (Mounted Infantry) Contingent, on 8 December 1900). [Main & Allen, D., (2002), pp.7-8.]

Charges dropped

Having returned to Australia under arrest, Reid had the reasonable expectation that he would be court-martialled. However, no official investigation of any kind was ever made into the circumstances of the publication of the letter; and, for some undisclosed reason, his case was unexpectedly dropped altogether.Main & Allen, D., (2002), p.8.]

In the absence of any "official" explanation", is reasonable to suppose that one or more of several possible influences may have played a part in the decision of the authorities not to proceed against Reid:
* His father and himself were ordained ministers of the Presbyterian Church (and, apparently, held in high regard). [Amongst other influential members of the first Australian Parliament were the member for Ballaarat, and the first Attorney General (later the Second Prime Minister of Australia), Alfred Deakin, who would have known both Reid and his father, and George Reid, later the Fourth Prime Minister of Australia, was not only a Presbyterian, but his father, also a Rev. John Reid, was also a Presbyterian Minister. George Reid had also attended Scotch College prior to moving to Sydney in 1858.]
* Despite still being part of the "Imperial Forces" when he returned to Australia on 8 December 1900 (effectively as a member of the military forces of the Colony of Western Australia), he was released after the Australian Commonwealth Government (in Commonwealth Gazette No. 9 of 20 February 1901) had authorized the formation of the Commonwealth Military Forces, effective from 1 March 1901. [ [http://www.defence.gov.au/Army/AHU/books_articles/Articles/Armys_Birthday.htm Lee, R., "The Army's Birthday - An Ongoing Debate"] .]
* The Sixth Western Australian (Mounted Infantry) Contingent, being composed of just 14 officers, 214 men, and 237 horses, [Burridge, (1972), p.27; [http://www.firstaif.info/west-aust/page/01-permanent.htm The Permanent (Military) Force in Western Australia] .] were greatly in need of the experience and leadership of a man who had already displayed great military talent in the South African conditions.
* His younger brother was also in the contingent.

Lieutenant Reid

Having been released from custody, Reid was promoted to Lieutenant on 7 March 1901, [ [http://www.awm.gov.au/nominalrolls/boer/person.asp?p=13381Boer War Nominal Roll: Stanley Spencer Reid] ] and he joined the Sixth Western Australian (Mounted Infantry) Contingent in camp at Karrakatta.

His younger brother, Surgeon-Captain Francis Bentley Reid, [ [http://www.awm.gov.au/nominalrolls/boer/person.asp?p=13354 Boer War Nominal Roll: Francis Bentley Reid] ] was medical officer to the same unit.

The entire contingent left Western Australia on 10 April 1901 on the "S.S. Ulstermore", and arrived in South Africa on 29 April 1901.

Reid's unit saw action in Eastern Transvaal; and, on 16 May 1901, Reid was badly wounded in the stomach in a heavy fire fight at a farm near Brakpan. [According to Chamberlain, (2004), p.46, Captain John Campbell [http://www.awm.gov.au/nominalrolls/boer/person.asp?p=2430 Australian War Memorial Boer War Nominal Roll: Captain John Campbell] attacked the Boer position with Lieutenants Reid and Harold Barry McCormack [http://www.awm.gov.au/nominalrolls/boer/person.asp?p=10349 Australian War Memorial Boer War Nominal Roll: Lieutenant Harold Barry McCormack] on his left, and Lieutenant Frederick William Bell [http://www.awm.gov.au/nominalrolls/boer/person.asp?p=1011 Australian War Memorial Boer War Nominal Roll: Lieutenant Frederick Willliam Bell] on his right. [http://cas.awm.gov.au/photograph/A03687 Australian War Memorial: Portrait of Lieutenant Frederick William Bell VC of the 6th West Australian Mounted Infantry] Bell won a Victoria Cross for his bravery. [http://www.awm.gov.au/honours/honours/person.asp?p=bE9151 Australian War Memorial, Honours and awards (gazetted): Frederick William Bell] .] Reid was taken to a field hospital 39 miles from Carolina. Both Reid and his brother were mentioned in despatches for their bravery at this time: [Stirling, (1907), pp.476-477. [http://www.awm.gov.au/honours/honours/person.asp?p=SA0227 Honours and awards: Stanley Spencer Reid (Mention in Despatches)] [http://www.awm.gov.au/honours/honours/person.asp?p=SA0230 Honours and awards: Francis Bentley Reid (Mention in Despatches)] ] quote| Lieutenant S S Reid at [Brakapan] … remained with his men though severely wounded early in the fight…
Surgeon-Captain F B Reid showed absolute disregard of danger in performing his duties on the same occasion". [Chamberlain, (2004), p.46 (Quoting from the despatch of Lord Kitchener).]

Reid recovered from his stomach wound and returned to action with his unit.

Death

On 23 June 1901, during a reconnaissance at Renshoogate, near Ermelo, [Murray, (1911) p.416, and Main & Allen, (2002), p.9 (no doubt using Murray as their source), give the name as Renshoogte. As there are no records (that is, other than those records directly traceable back to Murray) that use "Renshoogte" (other than, that is, the official listing in "The Times" of 6 July 1901), and as the Australian War Memorial records relating to this action all use "Renshoogate" — for example, see [http://www.awm.gov.au/roh/person.asp?p=142-570 Australian War Memorial Roll of Honour: George Westcott (413)] and [http://www.awm.gov.au/roh/person.asp?p=142-154 Australian War Memorial Roll of Honour: Clarence Chudleigh Clifford (348)] — and given that there seems to be no other trace of either "Renshoogte" or "Renshoogate" today (most likely wherever the place was, and whatever once existed there may well have been later razed to the ground by the British, as was the case with Carolina and Ermelo), it seems best to take the Australian War Memorial's version. Furthermore, in relation to Reid himself, Murray (1911, p.35) mistakenly has him returning to Australia on 26 January 1901, rather than on 8 December 1900; and, so, it may well be that his "Renshoogte" is just another inadvertent typographical error on Murray's part.] Reid was once again shot in the stomach. His brother placed Reid and the other wounded in an ambulance cart and set off back to their camp. Three days later, on the morning of 29 June 1901, Reid died at Middel-Kraal. A fellow officer, Lieutenant Bernard Bardwell, reported that "his brother, the doctor, was almost mad with grief". [Main & Allen, (2002), p.9.]

Reid, the second VFL player known to have died in active service, [The first was Charlie Moore who played 27 games (34 goals) for Essendon (he died on 5 May 1901 at Kwaggashoek Farm, Orange Free State, South Africa). Moore had been an opponent of Reid's in the 1898 Grand Final, Reid's last VFL match for Fitzroy.] is buried at the Middelburg Cemetery, Transvaal. [ [http://www.hagsoc.org.au/sagraves/photos/grave35.jpgGraves and Memorials of Australians in the Boer War 1899-1902: Middelburg Cemetery, Transvaal, Memorial to those who fell at Brakpan (Groblersrecht and Middelkraal)] .]

Remembered

In its 20 July 1901 tribute to Reid, "The Western Mail", having made reference to his academic and clerical careers, reported that Field Marshal Lord Roberts, the Commander in Chief of the British Forces in Second Boer War, had said of Reid: "He is one of the best men on the field of battle".Main & Allen, D., (2002), p.10.]

At the same time the newspaper observed that "his death has caused sorrow in many a home", and reported that a memorial service had been held in Boulder on Sunday 14 July 1901 for the town's former Presbyterian minister and that "many Roman Catholics and people of other denominations [had] attended to show their respect to the memory of one who had proved himself a man among men".

Stanley Simpson Reid is commemorated on war memorials at:
* Australian War Memorial, Canberra, Australian Capital Territory
* Caulfield Grammar School, St Kilda East, Victoria.
* King's Park, Perth, Western Australia [ [http://www.hagsoc.org.au/sagraves/photos/mem13.jpgHeraldry & Genealogy Society of Canberra Inc. — Graves and Memorials of Australians in the Boer War 1899-1902: Perth, WA, Kings Park (The King's Park Memorial)] ; [http://www.hagsoc.org.au/sagraves/photos/mem30.jpgHeraldry & Genealogy Society of Canberra Inc. — Graves and Memorials of Australians in the Boer War 1899-1902: Perth, WA, Kings Park (Foundation Stone)] ; [http://www.hagsoc.org.au/sagraves/photos/mem29.jpgHeraldry & Genealogy Society of Canberra Inc. — Graves and Memorials of Australians in the Boer War 1899-1902: Perth, WA, Kings Park (Reid's Memorial Inscription)] .]
* Ormond College, Parkville, Victoria.
* Scotch College, Hawthorn, Victoria.
* Middelburg Cemetery, Transvaal, South Africa. [ [http://www.hagsoc.org.au/sagraves/photos/grave35.jpgGraves and Memorials of Australians in the Boer War 1899-1902: Middelburg Cemetery, Transvaal, Memorial to those who fell at Brakpan (Groblersrecht and Middelkraal)] .]

ee also

* VFL/AFL players who died in active service
* 1898 VFL Grand Final

Footnotes

References

* Anon, "Boulder Clergyman Volunteers", "The West Australian", Vol.15, No.4312, (Thursday, 28 December 1899), p.5, col.G. [http://ndpbeta.nla.gov.au/ndp/del/article/3241282]
* Anon, "Summary of News", "The West Australian", Vol.15, No.4312, (Thursday, 28 December 1899), p.4, col.E. [http://ndpbeta.nla.gov.au/ndp/del/article/3241306]
* Anon, "The Presbyterian Church in Western Australia: A Twenty Years' Retrospect", "The West Australian", Vol.15, No.4312, (Saturday, 30 September 1899), p.10, col.C. [http://ndpbeta.nla.gov.au/ndp/del/article/3236039]
* Anon, "The War: Casualties", "The Times", No.36500, (Saturday, 6 July 1901), p.13, col.A.
* Anon, "The War: The Scottish Members of the Force; An Enthusiastic Send-Off", "The West Australian", Vol.16, No.4332, (Saturday, 20 January 1900), p.5, col.H. [http://ndpbeta.nla.gov.au/ndp/del/article/3242764]
* Anon, "The War: Western Australian Mounted Infantry; List of Men Enrolled", "The West Australian", Vol.15, No.4313, (Friday, 29 December 1899), p.5, col.F. [http://ndpbeta.nla.gov.au/ndp/del/article/3241364]
* Anon, "War Shots: A Warlike Parson", "Northern Territory Times and Gazette", Vol.22, No.1370, (Friday, 9 February 1900), p.3, col.E. [http://ndpbeta.nla.gov.au/ndp/del/page/826910]
* Atkinson, G., "The Complete Book of AFL Finals (2002 Edition)", The Five Mile Press, (Melbourne), 2002. ISBN 1-865-03892-X
* Burridge, J., "Western Australian Contingents to the South African War", John Burridge, (Perth), 1972. ISBN 0-959-89420-9
* Chamberlain, M., "The Action at Brakpan", "Sabretache: The Journal and Proceedings of the Military Historical Society of Australia", Vol.45, No.4, (September 2004), pp.41-46.
* Holmesby, R. & Main, J., "This Football Century: "The Greatest Game of All", Wilkinson Books, (Melbourne), 1996. ISBN 1-863-50222-X
* Lee, R., "The Army's Birthday: An Ongoing Debate", Army History Unit, (Canberra), 2004. [www.defence.gov.au/army/ahu/books_articles/Articles/Armys_Birthday.htm]
* Main, J. & Allen, D., "Reid, Stanley", pp.7-10 in Main, J. & Allen, D., "Fallen — The Ultimate Heroes: Footballers Who Never Returned From War", Crown Content, (Melbourne), 2002. ISBN 1-740-95010-0
* Main, J. & Holmesby, R., "The Encyclopedia of AFL Footballers", Crown Content, (Melbourne), (2002). ISBN 1-740-95032-1
* Murray, P.L. (ed), "Official Records of the Australian Military Contingents to the War in South Africa", A.J. Mullett, Govt. Printer, (Melbourne), 1911.
* Rogers, S. & Brown, A., "Every Game Ever Played: VFL/AFL Results 1897-1997 (Sixth Edition)", Viking Books, (Ringwood), 1998. ISBN 0-670-90809-6
* Stirling, J.F., "The Colonials in South Africa, 1899-1902: Their Record, Based on the Despatches", W.Blackwood and Sons, (Edinburgh), 1907.
* Webber, Horace, "Years may pass on . . . Caulfield Grammar School, 1881-1981", Centenary Committee, Caulfield Grammar School, (East St Kilda), 1981. ISBN 0-9594242-0-2

External links

* [http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/players/S/Stan_Reid.html AFL Player Statistics: Stan Reid]
* [http://stats.afl.com.au/public/statistics/player_roundbyround/1897/7/player_roundbyround_7_1897.shtml?club_idIndex=5&season_idIndex=110 AFL Player Statistics (Round by Round): Fitzroy Football Club 1897]
* [http://stats.afl.com.au/public/statistics/player_roundbyround/1898/7/player_roundbyround_7_1898.shtml?club_idIndex=5&season_idIndex=109 AFL Player Statistics (Round by Round): Fitzroy Football Club 1898]
* [http://members.iinet.net.au/~perthdps/military/bor-wa6.htm Western Australians in the Boer War — Sixth (Western Australian Mounted Infantry) Contingent — this contains information extracted from Murray (1911)]
* [http://www.awm.gov.au/nominalrolls/boer/person.asp?p=13381 Boer War Nominal Roll: Stanley Spencer Reid]
* [http://www.awm.gov.au/honours/honours/person.asp?p=SA0227 Honours and awards: Stanley Spencer Reid (Mention in Despatches)]
* [http://www.awm.gov.au/roh/person.asp?p=142-452 Australian War Memorial Roll of Honour: Stanley Spencer Reid]
* [http://www.awm.gov.au/nominalrolls/boer/person.asp?p=13354 Boer War Nominal Roll: Francis Bentley Reid]
* [http://www.awm.gov.au/honours/honours/person.asp?p=SA0230 Honours and awards: Francis Bentley Reid (Mention in Despatches)]
* [http://www.awm.gov.au/roh/person.asp?p=142-570 Australian War Memorial Roll of Honour: George Westcott (413)]
* [http://www.awm.gov.au/roh/person.asp?p=142-154 Australian War Memorial Roll of Honour: Clarence Chudleigh Clifford (348)]
* [http://www.australianrules.com.au/2004stories/top10anzac.html Paul Daffey, "The 10 best Anzac club links", "The Sunday Age", 25 April 2004]
* [http://www.afl.com.au/TheClub/History/FitzroyLions/FitzroyFirsts/tabid/5177/Default.aspx "Fitzroy Firsts: Etched in History", (Bisbane Lions Football Club Official Website, 1 May 2006)]
* [http://www.hagsoc.org.au/sagraves/photos/memw0001.php Heraldry & Genealogy Society of Canberra Inc. — Graves and Memorials of Australians in the Boer War 1899-1902: Photographs (Perth, WA, Kings Park)]